Content deleted Content added
m →Secondary source material: HTTP→HTTPS for The New York Times. using AWB |
Animadversor (talk | contribs) m →top: Fixed typo Tags: Mobile edit Mobile app edit Android app edit |
||
(43 intermediate revisions by 27 users not shown) | |||
Line 1:
{{Short description|People's assembly in ancient rome}}{{Roman government}}
The '''Curiate Assembly''' (''comitia curiata'') was the principal assembly during the first two decades of the [[Roman Republic]]. During these first decades, the People of Rome were organized into thirty units called "[[Curia]]e".<ref name="Byrd, 33">Byrd, 33</ref><ref name="Taylor, 3, 4">Taylor, 3, 4</ref> The Curiae were ethnic in nature, and thus were organized on the basis of the early Roman family, or, more specifically, on the basis of the thirty original [[Patrician (ancient Rome)|Patrician]] (aristocratic) clans.<ref name="Abbott, 250">Abbott, 250</ref> The Curiae formed an assembly for legislative, electoral, and judicial purposes. The Curiate Assembly passed laws, elected [[Roman Consul|Consuls]] (the only elected magistrates at the time),<ref name="Abbott, 253">Abbott, 253</ref> and tried judicial cases. Consuls always presided over the assembly. While [[Plebeian]]s (commoners) could participate in this assembly, only the Patricians (the Roman aristocrats) could vote.▼
▲The '''Curiate Assembly''' (''comitia curiata'') was the principal assembly
Since the Romans used a form of Direct Democracy, citizens, and not elected representatives, voted before each assembly. As such, the citizen-electors had no power, other than the power to cast a vote. Each assembly was presided over by a single Roman Magistrate, and as such, it was the presiding magistrate who made all decisions on matters of procedure and legality. Ultimately, the presiding magistrate's power over the assembly was nearly absolute. The only check on that power came in the form of vetoes handed down by other magistrates, and decisions made by presiding magistrates could also be vetoed by higher-ranking magistrates. In addition, after 493 BC, any decision made by a presiding magistrate, including one concerning the Curiate Assembly, could be vetoed by a magistrate known as a [[Plebeian Tribune]] or more popularly called a "Tribune of the Plebs".▼
▲Since the Romans used a form of
In the Roman system of [[direct democracy]], primary types of gatherings were used to vote on legislative, electoral, and judicial matters. The first was the Assembly (''comitia'', literally "going together" or "meeting place").<ref name="Lintott, 42">Lintott, 42</ref> The Curiate Assembly was a ''comitia''. Assemblies represented ''all citizens'',<ref name="Abbott, 251">Abbott, 251</ref> even if they excluded the [[plebs]] like the Curiate Assembly did, and were used for official purposes, such as for the enactment of statutes. Acts of an Assembly applied to all Roman citizens. The second type of gathering was the Council (''concilium''), which was a forum where a specific class of citizen met. In contrast, the Convention (''conventio'', literally "coming together") was an unofficial forum for communication. Conventions were simply forums where Romans met for specific unofficial purposes, such as, for example, to hear a political speech.<ref name="Lintott, 42">Lintott, 42</ref> Private citizens who did not hold political office could only speak before a Convention, and not before an Assembly or a Council.<ref name="Abbott, 252">Abbott, 252</ref> Conventions were simply meetings, and no legal or legislative decisions could be made in them. Voters always assembled first into Conventions to hear debates and conduct other business before voting, and then into Assemblies or Councils to vote.<ref name="Taylor, 2">Taylor, 2</ref>▼
==Procedure==
▲In the Roman system of [[direct democracy]], primary types of gatherings were used to vote on legislative, electoral, and judicial matters. The first was the Assembly (''comitia'', literally "going together" or "meeting place").<ref name="
[[File:Roman constitution.png|thumb|left|500px|Chart Showing the Checks and Balances of the [[Constitution of the Roman Republic]]]]
A notice always had to be given several days before the Assembly was to vote. For elections, at least three market-days (often more than seventeen actual days) had to pass between the announcement of the election, and the actual election. During this time period (the ''trinundinum''), the candidates interacted with the electorate, and no legislation could be proposed or voted upon. In 98 BC, a statute was passed (the ''lex Caecilia Didia'') which required a similar three market-day interval to pass between the proposal of a statute and the vote on that statute.
Only one assembly could operate at any given point in time, and any session already underway could be dissolved if a magistrate "called away" (''avocare'') the electors.
On the day of the vote, the electors first assembled into their Conventions for debate and campaigning.<ref name="
The electors were then told to break up the Convention ("depart to your separate groups", or ''discedite, quirites''). The electors assembled behind a fenced off area<ref name="
==Decline
Shortly after the founding of the republic, many of the political powers of the Curiate Assembly were transferred to the [[Centuriate Assembly]] and the [[Tribal Assembly]].<ref name="byrd-33" /> This included the transfer of the election of tribunes to the Tribal Assembly by the [[Lex Publilia (471 BC)|Lex Publilia]] in 471 BC.<ref>[[Livy]], ''[[Ab urbe condita libri (Livy)|Ab urbe condita]]'', ii. 58.</ref>
Shortly after the founding of the republic, the powers of the Curiate Assembly were transferred to the [[Centuriate Assembly]] and the [[Tribal Assembly]].<ref name="Byrd, 33">Byrd, 33</ref> While it then fell into disuse, it did retain some theoretical powers, most importantly, the power to ratify elections of the top-ranking [[Roman Magistrates]] (Consuls and [[Praetors]]) by passing a law (''[[lex curiata de imperio]]'' or "Curiate Law on Imperium") that gave them their legal command ([[Imperium]]) authority. In practice, however, they received this authority from the Centuriate Assembly (which formally elected them), and as such, this functioned as nothing more than a reminder of Rome's regal heritage.<ref name="Taylor, 3, 4">Taylor, 3, 4</ref> Even after it lost its powers, the Curiate Assembly continued to be presided over by Consuls and Praetors, and was subject to obstruction by [[Roman Magistrates]] (especially [[tribune|Plebeian Tribunes]]) and unfavorable omens (as were the other assemblies).<ref name="Taylor, 3, 4">Taylor, 3, 4</ref> Acts that the Curiate Assembly voted on were mostly symbolic and usually in the affirmative.<ref name="Taylor, 3, 4">Taylor, 3, 4</ref> At one point, possibly as early as 218 BC, the Curiate Assembly's thirty Curiae were abolished, and replaced with thirty [[lictors]], one from each of the original Patrician clans.<ref name="Taylor, 3, 4">Taylor, 3, 4</ref>▼
▲
Since the Curiae had always been organized on the basis of the Roman family,<ref name="Abbott, 250">Abbott, 250</ref> it retained jurisdiction over clan matters even after the fall of the [[Roman Republic]] in 27 BC.<ref name="Abbott, 253">Abbott, 253</ref> Under the presidency of the [[Pontifex Maximus]],<ref name="Byrd, 33">Byrd, 33</ref> it witnessed wills and ratified adoptions,<ref name="Byrd, 33">Byrd, 33</ref> inaugurated certain priests, and transfer citizens from Patrician class to Plebeian class (or vice versa). In 59 BC, it transferred [[Publius Clodius Pulcher]] from Patrician status to Plebeian status so that he could run for Plebeian Tribune. In 44 BC, it ratified the will of [[Julius Caesar]], and with it Caesar's adoption of his nephew Gaius Octavian (the future [[Roman Emperor]] [[Augustus]]) as his son and heir.<ref name="Taylor, 3, 4">Taylor, 3, 4</ref>▼
By the time of the middle and late Republic, there was considerable debate about the need for confirmation in imperium by the Curiate assembly. For example, ''praetors'' were not permitted to undertake judicial business without confirmation in the ''imperium'' nor could ''consuls'' command troops or call the ''comitia centuriata'' to hold the election of his successor.<ref name="Botsworth190">{{Cite book |title=The Roman Assemblies |last=Botsworth |first=George Willis |publisher=Cooper Square Publishers, Inc |year=1909 |publication-place=New York |page=190 }}</ref> Cicero's contemporaries argued that without confirmation in the imperium, a magistrate could not act as a promagistrate, or without it, govern the province at his own expense and be ineligible for a triumph after a military victory.<ref name="Botsworth190" /> These rules would have prohibited magistrates from engaging in serious public business before confirmation, but for the fact they were widely ignored and legislation often included provisions stating that in the lack of a curiate law, they "be magistrates in as legal a sense as those who are elected according to the strictest forms of law".<ref name="Botsworth190" /> By 212 BC, the lack of such a law granting imperium to the propraetor of Spain, Lucius Marcius, was no issue for the senate, which refrained from declaring the election illegal.{{sfn|Botsworth|1909|p=192}} During the late Republic, by 54, the consul Appius Claudius insisted that he held imperium, due to statute passed by Sulla granting imperium to promagistrates until their return to the city without mention of the curiate grant of imperium, and also that he held the authority to call the Assembly to elect new magistrates.{{sfn| Botsworth |1909|p=193}} However, in the late Republic, with increasing conflict between the ''optimates'' and the ''populares'', it is likely that the senate, trying to increase its control over provincial governors, stressed the importance of this law, even as magistrates ignored their complaints.{{sfn| Botsworth |1909|p=198}}
Acts that the Curiate Assembly voted on were mostly symbolic and usually in the affirmative.<ref name="Taylor, 3, 4">Taylor, 3, 4</ref> At one point, possibly as early as 218 BC, the Curiate Assembly's thirty Curiae were abolished, and replaced with thirty [[lictors]], one from each of the original Patrician clans.<ref name="Taylor, 3, 4">Taylor, 3, 4</ref>
▲Since the Curiae had always been organized on the basis of the Roman family,<ref name="Abbott, 250">Abbott, 250</ref> it retained jurisdiction over clan matters even after the fall of the [[Roman Republic]] in 27 BC.<ref name="Abbott, 253">Abbott, 253</ref> Under the presidency of the [[Pontifex Maximus]],<ref name="
With the rise of the empire, the sanctioning powers of the Curiate assembly fell into disuse, as the power to grant ''imperium'', along with the vast majority of the other powers of the Curiate assembly, were transferred into the hands of the Senate or delegated to the emperor through a special ''lex de imperio''.<ref name="taylor428">{{Cite book|title=A Constitutional and Political History of Rome|url=https://archive.org/details/aconstitutional00taylgoog|last=Taylor|first=Thomas Marris|publisher=Methuen & Co|year=1899|location=London|page=[https://archive.org/details/aconstitutional00taylgoog/page/n442 428]}}</ref>
==See also==
{{div col |colwidth=15em}}
* [[Roman Kingdom]]
* [[Roman Republic]]
Line 72 ⟶ 39:
* [[Plebeian Council]]
* [[Centuria]]
* [[Curia]]
* [[Roman consul]]
Line 79 ⟶ 45:
* [[Quaestor]]
* [[Aedile]]
* [[Roman Dictator]]
* [[Master of the Horse]]
Line 86 ⟶ 51:
* [[Byzantine Senate]]
* [[Pontifex Maximus]]
* [[Princeps senatus]]
* [[Interrex]]
* [[Procurator (Roman)]]
* [[Acta Senatus]]
{{div col end}}
==Notes==▼
==References==
{{refbegin}}
* {{cite book|last1=Abbott
* Botsford, George Willis (1909, repr. 2005). ''The Roman Assemblies. From their Origin to the End of the Republic'', New York.
* Byrd, Robert (1995). ''The Senate of the Roman Republic''. U.S. Government Printing Office, Senate Document 103-23.
* [[Andrew Lintott|Lintott, Andrew]] (1999). ''The Constitution of the Roman Republic''. Oxford University Press ({{ISBN
{{refend}}
* Polybius (1823). ''The General History of Polybius: Translated from the Greek''. By [[James Hampton (priest)|James Hampton]]. Oxford: Printed by W. Baxter. Fifth Edition, Vol 2.
* [[Lily Ross Taylor|Taylor, Lily Ross]] (1966). ''Roman Voting Assemblies: From the Hannibalic War to the Dictatorship of Caesar''. The University of Michigan Press ({{ISBN
* [[Cicero|Tullius Cicero, Marcus]] (1841 edition). ''The Political Works of Marcus Tullius Cicero: Comprising his Treatise on the Commonwealth; and his Treatise on the Laws. Translated from the original, with Dissertations and Notes in Two Volumes''. By Francis Barham, Esq. London: Edmund Spettigue. Vol. 1.
▲==Notes==
▲{{reflist|4}}
==Further reading==
Line 125 ⟶ 89:
===Primary sources===
* [http://oll.libertyfund.org/?option=com_staticxt&staticfile=show.php%3Ftitle=546&chapter=83299&layout=html&Itemid=27 Cicero's De Re Publica, Book Two]
* [http://www.fordham.edu/HALSALL/ANCIENT/polybius6.html Rome at the End of the Punic Wars: An Analysis of the Roman Government; by Polybius] {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20070205073306/http://www.fordham.edu/HALSALL/ANCIENT/polybius6.html |date=2007-02-05 }}
===Secondary source material===
Line 131 ⟶ 95:
* [https://web.archive.org/web/20080829134354/http://www.uah.edu/student_life/organizations/SAL/texts/misc/romancon.html The Roman Constitution to the Time of Cicero]
* [https://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/30/opinion/30harris.html?_r=1&oref=slogin What a Terrorist Incident in Ancient Rome Can Teach Us]
==External links==
{{Library resources box |by=no |onlinebooks=yes |others=yes |about=yes |label=Curiate Assembly
|viaf= |lccn= |lcheading= |wikititle= }}
{{Roman Constitution}}
{{Ancient Rome topics}}
[[Category:Government of the Roman Kingdom
[[Category:Government of the Roman Republic]]
[[Category:Government of the Roman Empire]]
[[Category:Roman law]]
[[Category:Popular assemblies]]
|