Wikipedia

LGBTQ rights in Bhutan

Lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people in Bhutan face legal challenges that are not faced by non-LGBTQ people. Bhutan does not provide any anti-discrimination laws for LGBT people, and same-sex unions are not recognised. However, same-sex sexual activity was decriminalised in Bhutan on 17 February 2021.

LGBTQ rights in Bhutan
Bhutan
StatusLegal since 2021
Gender identityNo
MilitaryNo
Discrimination protectionsNo
Family rights
Recognition of relationshipsNo
AdoptionNo

In recent years, due to opening up more to the outside world, Bhutanese LGBT people have started to publicly come out and establish visible outlets for the LGBT community. Therefore, attitudes among the general population are changing.[1]

Legality of same-sex sexual activity

edit

As amended in 2021, Section 213 of the Bhutan Penal Code states:[2]

A defendant shall be guilty of the offence of unnatural sex, if the defendant engages in sexual conduct that is against the order of nature. However, homosexuality between adults shall not be considered unnatural sex.

Previously, the code said a defendant was guilty of unnatural sex "if the defendant engages in sodomy or any other sexual conduct that is against the order of nature."[3] This law jailed LGBT people up to a year with fines.

Efforts to repeal the sodomy ban began in 2019, during a review of the Penal Code. In December 2020, the Parliament of Bhutan passed legislation decriminalizing same-sex sexual activity with 63 votes in favor and 6 abstentions.[4][5] The bill was signed into law and took effect on 17 February 2021.[2] The age of consent is set at 18 years old, regardless of gender.

Decriminalisation process

edit

Some members of the Parliament of Bhutan had publicly called for the laws to be repealed as early as 2013.[6]

On 29 May 2019, the Penal Code (Amendment) Bill 2019 (Dzongkha: འབྲུག་གི་ཞིས་འགེལ་ཁྲིམས་དེབ་༼འཕྲི་སྣོན༽ དཔྱད་ཡིག་ ༢༠༡༩) was introduced by the Chairperson of the Legislative Committee, MP Tshewang Lhamo (DNT), to the Parliament. At first, the removal of sections 213 and 214 was not proposed in the bill. However, the Minister of Finance, Namgay Tshering (DNT), suggested the change as a comment and said that section 213 should be changed "to keep up with the times". The Legislative Committee of the National Assembly was supportive. When the bill was referred to the Legislative Committee, it decided to take the Finance Minister's suggestion seriously, and asked him to give it in writing, which the Finance Minister agreed to do, and allowing the committee the ability to propose it as an amendment. Tshering said "My primary reason is that this section is there since 2004 but it has become so redundant and has never been enforced. It is also an eyesore for international human rights bodies.", and that the sections had become "a stain" on the country's reputation.[7][8]

On 7 June 2019, the National Assembly approved the bill in a first reading.[9][10][11] On 10 June 2019, the bill passed the second and final reading with 38 votes in favour and 1 vote against, with 5 absentations. The bill was sent to the National Council for the winter session 6 months later.[12][13][14] On 10 February 2020, the Council approved it with amendments by 19 votes in favour and 6 abstentions.[15] Having been amended, the bill was sent back to the lower house, which adopted it on 27 February by a vote of 34–1 with 7 abstentions, but rejected 32 of the 56 amendments proposed by the upper house. This meant that the legislation was sent to a joint committee for reviews and voted on by a joint sitting of both chambers.[16] The joint committee convened on 7 October 2020.[17] In December 2020, the Parliament passed the bill with 63 votes in favor and 6 abstentions in the joint sitting,[18] decriminalizing same-sex sexual activity. The bill was signed into law by King Jigme Khesar Namgyel Wangchuck,[5] and came into force on 17 February 2021.[19][20]

Recognition of same-sex relationship

edit
Main article: Recognition of same-sex unions in Bhutan

Bhutan does not provide any form of legal recognition for same-sex couples.

Tashi Tsheten, director of Rainbow Bhutan, said that a marriage bill with gender-neutral pronouns was discussed during the 2018 summer parliamentary session but was deferred due to the 2018 parliamentary election. However, a progressive government was elected in that election, and Tsheten and the LGBT community expressed their belief that the conversation around the bill would be revived.[21]

Living conditions

edit

Ignorance about homosexuality is common due to stereotypes in popular culture.[22] Bhutanese culture does not share the typical Western view of heterosexuality and homosexuality. Some have referred to it as an openly bisexual society, although this is disputed.[23] Women are more likely than men to be open about their sexual orientation.[24] There are cultural and traditional struggles for those who seek acceptance.[24] According to a 2016 Integrated Biological and Behavioral Surveillance (IBBS) survey, over 42% of transgender women and 23% of gay and bisexual men in Bhutan had attempted suicide more than once. The survey also found that transgender women and gay and bisexual men were often victims of "extreme physical and sexual violence".[25] According to a 2019 study conducted to see how sections 213 and 214 affected the community, 69% of the respondents felt the two clauses impacted them negatively.[26]

In 2013, the introduction of Facebook led to increased visibility for the LGBT community with the creation of dedicated Facebook groups. In 2014, Rainbow Bhutan was set up as a community for LGBT people with five members; this grew to 136 members in 2019.[26] In 2019, LGBT activist Tashi Tsheten said that the full LGBT movement started from 2015 onwards when the community started organising programmes on HIV. In 2017, LGBT groups began advocating outside of the scope of HIV/AIDS and began working more in the open.[27] In 2015, activist and physiotherapist Passang Dorji came out as gay for the first time on national television.[28] In February 2015, Karma Dupchen, a civil engineer and LGBT activist, created LGBT Bhutan, Bhutan's first ever Facebook page dedicated to spread awareness about the LGBT community.[29]

Buddhism, the main religion of Bhutan, does not condemn homosexuality. In 2015, Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche, Bhutan's most prominent Buddhist teacher, said that sexual orientation has nothing to do with who will reach enlightenment. He further stated that Bhutanese should not merely tolerate gay people but should respect them. He said, "Your sexual orientation has nothing to do with understanding or not understanding the truth. You could be gay, you could be lesbian, you could be straight, we never know which one will get enlightened first… Tolerance is not a good thing. If you are tolerating this, it means that you think it's something wrong that you will tolerate. But you have to go beyond that – you have to respect."[30][31]

Bhutan Observer, one of the country's main weekly newspapers, has written a significant number of articles on LGBT issues which elicited a lot of interest, making them the most commented articles on the paper's website.[32] The government-supported newspaper Kuensel, meanwhile, has referred to gays as being the "Third Gender" in an article discussing HIV programmes targeted towards gay men.[33] In November 2017, a presentation to sensibilise senior police officers on the stigmatisation faced by LGBT people was held in Phuentsholing. Police officials said the presentation sensitised them further and made them understand issues related to the LGBT community. Chief of Police Colonel Chimi Dorji said, "After the training, we will come up with a procedural guidebook on LGBT. We will then distribute it among the officers. It will help us to deal with the LGBT community in a free and fair manner".[34]

The International Day Against Homophobia, Transphobia and Biphobia was first celebrated in Bhutan in 2016. United Nations offices in the country launched a video campaign to defend the rights of LGBT people.[35] The LGBT pride flag was flown in the country for the first time, at the UN House in Thimphu.[36] In 2018, the event was celebrated at Hotel Migmar with government representatives as well as from civil society and the media.[37] The event has been observed each year ever since.[38]

There is no annual gay pride parade or other public display in Bhutan.[39] LGBT activist Tashi Tsheten has said that they do not plan on holding one, not because of a hostile environment or oppressive government, but because "pride parades are a form of activism where people go out on the streets and talk about policy and legal changes; and that's not something that Bhutanese agree with. We believe in building human relations and talking one-to-one. Connecting heart-to-heart. That's where the real change happens".[27]

Deyon Phuntsho and Tenzin Gyeltshen, a same-sex couple who went public with their relationship in 2018, reported being fully accepted by their families and friends.[40][41]

Tashi Tsheten, director of Rainbow Bhutan, said although there was a general acceptance of transgender people, especially in rural areas, they still face much discrimination, especially in schools, saying that "there are lots of barriers and our education system does not understand LGBT," adding that most LGBT youths drop out of school.[39]

In 2022, Bhutan's Finance Minister Namgay Tshering claimed that "there is a high degree of acceptability of the LGBT+ community in our society". In the same year, Tashi Choden Chombal, an openly lesbian woman was crowned Miss Bhutan 2022 and represented Bhutan in the Miss Universe 2022 pageant.[42]

Terminology

edit

In 2015, the Dzongkha Development Commission, which seeks to promote and protect the Dzongkha language and introduce new words, announced Dzongkha terms for lesbian (མོ་སྦྱོར།), gay (མཚུངས་སྦྱོར།), bisexual (ཟུང་སྦྱོར།), transgender (མཚན་སྒྱུར།), transvestite (སྤྱོད་སྒྱུར།), intersex (མ་ནིང།), homosexuality (འདྲ་སྦྱོར།), and homophobia (མཚུངས་སྦྱོར་ཞན་ལོག).[43][44]

The word "chakka" is an Indian slang term used as a slur for gay and effeminate men.[45] The word "phomenmomen", meaning not male and not female, is used to label a gay person, but a more correct translation might be "intersex". Gay Bhutanese do not like nor use this word.[46] Gay men themselves use English terms to describe themselves: "gay king" is an older top, "gay queen" is an older bottom, "freaking prince" is a young top, "freaking princess" is a young bottom, and "closet celebrity" refers to a closeted man that everyone knows is gay.[46]

Political support

edit

LGBT activist Tashi Tsheten said that, previously, in 2009 and 2010, Bhutanese officials would state at international conferences that the country had no homosexuals at all.[28]

Dasho Neten Zangmo, the head of Bhutan's Anti-Corruption Commission described as "the most important woman in the country" and the "Iron Lady of Bhutan", was the first senior Bhutanese government official to make a comment about gay Bhutanese, when she said in a speech in August 2014 to high school students: "Romantic relationships, by the way, can be boy-boy or girl-girl."[30]

In 2016, two Bhutanese National Assembly members, Madan Kumar Chhetri and Ugyen Wangdi, attended the Salzburg Global LGBT Forum, hosted by the Salzburg Global Seminar and held in Chiang Rai, Thailand, alongside two Bhutanese LGBT rights activists.[31]

The Bhutan Kuen-Nyam Party (BKP) has expressed support for LGBT rights.[47] In 2018, the party included the rights of LGBT people in their manifesto for the 2018 Bhutanese National Assembly election.[21]

In June 2019, during the parliamentary debate on the decriminalisation of homosexuality, some MPs called for enacting legislation granting LGBT people some rights. MP Tshewang Lhamo (DNT), the chairperson of the Legislative Committee said, "A lot of people are affected in our society because of Sections 213 and 214. We must understand that laws need to be changed as per the changing times. Everyone should have the freedom of choice. We only consider male preferring female and vis-à-vis as natural, and anything beyond that as unnatural. People must know that everyone is equal before the law irrespective of who they are. This particular Section 213 discriminates against a section of people and this is the reason why our committee has come up with a proposal to remove this section."[48] MP Kinley Wangchuk (DNT) said, "Even if there is no harm, we must not look at the law based not only on the country-level, but globally. It's also not fine if it is kept as it is. On a global level, outsiders might think there is no law at all meant for LGBT community and that they are considered as an invisible section of society, which might create a suspicion. Rather than removing the section, it's also important that we make a clear legal rights for them first". MP Jurmi Wangchuk (DNT) echoed Kinley Wangchuk's statement.[49]

Public opinion

edit

One of the first LGBT-related opinion polls in Bhutan carried out by an exchange student at the Royal Thimphu College on campus with 150 participants resulted in the following responses in 2013. 60% of the respondents believed that homosexuality is immoral and 40% believed that homosexuality should be accepted and homosexuals protected from discrimination and harm.[22]

Demographics

edit

According to 2018 estimates from the United Nations Development Programme, there were about 9,100 men who have sex with men in the capital Thimphu.[40]

In 2019, the government-supported newspaper Kuensel stated that there were 316 people registered as LGBT in the country. Of these, 3 were lesbian, 21 transgender women, 31 transgender men, 3 bisexual women, 16 bisexual men, and 62 gay. 10 were below the age of 19 years, 93 were between 20 and 30 years, and 33 above 30 years.[26] This number was 97 in 2017 and 118 in 2018.[50]

HIV/AIDS

edit

Lhak-Sam (BNP+) is the country's first association of HIV positive people. The association was formed in September 2009 and was registered as a civil society organization in November 2010[51] by executive director Wangda Dorji. Lhak-Sam has gained support from Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS and other international organizations as well as Bhutan's Ministry of Health.[52]

Although gay and bisexual men are 19 times more vulnerable and transgender women are approximately 34-47 times more vulnerable to HIV infections, as of 2018 Bhutan has only one recorded case of HIV infection in the LGBT community.[25][50]

Human rights reports

edit

2017 United States Department of State report

edit

In 2017, the United States Department of State reported the following, concerning the status of LGBT rights in Bhutan:

  • Acts of Violence, Discrimination, and Other Abuses Based on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity
    "The constitution guarantees equal protection of the laws and application of rights but does not explicitly protect individuals from discrimination for sexual orientation or gender identity. Laws against "sodomy or any other sexual conduct that is against the order of nature" exist. The penal code imposes penalties of up to one year in prison for engaging in prohibited sexual conduct.
    Members of the LGBTI community reported instances of discrimination and social stigma based on sexual orientation.
    The law does not provide any distinct legal status to transgender individuals, nor does it provide explicit protections."[53]

Summary table

edit
Right Legal status
Same-sex sexual activity legal   (Since 2021)
Equal age of consent (18)   (Since 2021)
Anti-discrimination laws in employment only  
Anti-discrimination laws in the provision of goods and services  
Anti-discrimination laws in all other areas (incl. indirect discrimination, hate speech)  
Same-sex marriage  
Recognition of same-sex couples  
Stepchild adoption by same-sex couples  
Joint adoption by same-sex couples  
LGBT people allowed to serve openly in the military  
Right to change legal gender  
Gender self-identification  
Legal recognition of non-binary gender  
Access to IVF for lesbians  
Commercial surrogacy for gay male couples  
MSMs, transgender people or lesbians allowed to donate blood  [54]

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ Ryan, Hugh (28 October 2015). "Gay in Nirvana: Bhutan's LGBT Population Emerges from the Shadows". The Daily Beast – via www.thedailybeast.com.
  2. ^ a b "Bhutan Penal Code Amendment Act 2021" (PDF).
  3. ^ State-sponsored Homophobia A world survey of laws prohibiting same sex activity between consenting adultsArchived 17 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine
  4. ^ "National Assembly of Bhutan". www.nab.gov.bt. Retrieved 9 February 2021..
  5. ^ a b "Bhutan parliament decriminalizes homosexuality, to delight of activists". The Times of India. 10 December 2020. Retrieved 11 December 2020.
  6. ^ Potts, Andrew (16 September 2013). "Bhutan lawmaker says law criminalizing gays may go". Gay Star News. Archived from the original on 7 June 2019. Retrieved 7 June 2019.
  7. ^ "Bhutan decriminalizes homosexuality". The Daily Star. 9 June 2019.
  8. ^ Kumari, Pradamini (10 June 2019). "Bhutan's Parliament Decriminalises Homosexuality, The LGBTQ Community Celebrates". ScoopWhoop.
  9. ^ Sarrubba, Stefania (7 June 2019). "Bhutan starts process to decriminalize homosexuality". Gay Star News. Archived from the original on 7 June 2019. Retrieved 7 June 2019.
  10. ^ Brown, Steve (7 June 2019). "Himalayan kingdom of Bhutan removes sections of penal code that criminalise homosexuality". Attitude. Archived from the original on 7 June 2019. Retrieved 7 June 2019.
  11. ^ Pal, Alasdair (7 June 2019). "Bhutan's lower house of parliament votes to decriminalise homosexuality". Reuters. Archived from the original on 7 June 2019. Retrieved 7 June 2019.
  12. ^ "Twitter". mobile.twitter.com.
  13. ^ "Buddhist Kingdom of Bhutan Moves to Decriminalize Homosexuality – Buddhistdoor". www.buddhistdoor.net.
  14. ^ "National Assembly takes a big step towards decriminalizing Homosexuality".
  15. ^ NC adopts the Civil and Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment) Bill 2019 and the Penal Code (Amendment) Bill 2019
  16. ^ National Assembly re-deliberates and passes the Penal Code (Amendment) Bill of Bhutan 2019
  17. ^ "National Council of Bhutan". www.nationalcouncil.bt. Retrieved 26 January 2021.
  18. ^ "National Assembly of Bhutan". www.nab.gov.bt. Retrieved 9 February 2021..
  19. ^ "Bhutan drops its law against sodomy". Erasing 76 Crimes. https://facebook.comErasing76Crimes. 11 March 2021. Retrieved 12 March 2021..
  20. ^ "2021 penal code" (PDF). www.nab.gov.bt. Retrieved 12 March 2021..
  21. ^ a b "Bhutan prepares to repeal its anti-gay laws". Erasing 76 Crimes. 10 June 2019.
  22. ^ a b "Bhutan's underground gay community seeks acceptance". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 16 September 2013. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
  23. ^ "Bhutan – GlobalGayz". www.globalgayz.com.
  24. ^ a b "More equal or less equal?". Archived from the original on 31 December 2014. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
  25. ^ a b "Amid Widespread Stigma and Harassment, Bhutan's LGBT Community Seeks Acceptance". The Wire. 7 November 2017.
  26. ^ a b c "Feeling recognised and included". Kuensel. 15 June 2019.
  27. ^ a b Tsheten, Tashi (13 June 2019). "I Am A Queer Bhutanese, and My Country Is on Its Way to Scrapping Anti-LGBTQ Laws". Vice News.
  28. ^ a b Haidar, Suhasini (23 June 2019). "Sunlight on Bhutan's rainbow laws". The Hindu.
  29. ^ "Limelight: Karma Dupchen (Bhutan)". apcom.org. 22 June 2015. Archived from the original on 15 July 2019. Retrieved 15 July 2019.
  30. ^ a b "To Be, or Not to Be, in Bhutan – The Gay & Lesbian Review". March 2016.
  31. ^ a b Hallman, Louise (29 January 2018). "Happiness and Harmonization – LGBT Laws in Bhutan". Salzburg Global Seminar.
  32. ^ Wangmo, Phuntsho (19 December 2008). "How Gay Are Bhutanese Gays?". Bhutan Observer online. Archived from the original on 15 April 2017. Retrieved 14 April 2017.
  33. ^ Pelden, Sonam (28 November 2011). "Healthcare for the third gender". Kuensel online. Retrieved 28 November 2011.[permanent dead link]
  34. ^ "Police to come up with procedural guidebook on LGBT community". Bhutan Broadcasting Service. 29 November 2017.
  35. ^ "Welcome to IDAHOT Newbies !". 17 May 2016.
  36. ^ Dema, Tshering (17 May 2016). "Rainbow flag flown for the first time in the country". Bhutan Broadcasting Service.
  37. ^ Tshomo, Dechen (21 May 2018). "All the way to Bhutan-Activists celebrated IDAHOTB 2018". may17.org.
  38. ^ "Members of Rainbow Bhutan – A LGBT Community Oberserves IDAHOT". Daily Bhutan. 26 May 2018.
  39. ^ a b "Bhutan gays celebrate after homosexuality decriminalised". CNA. Archived from the original on 9 June 2019. Retrieved 10 June 2019.
  40. ^ a b "Bhutan's first public Gay couple receive positive responses after coming out – The Bhutanese".
  41. ^ "Bhutan's first openly gay couple get nothing but love from the public". Gay Star News. 12 February 2018. Archived from the original on 21 March 2019. Retrieved 17 May 2018.
  42. ^ "Are LGBTQ rights blossoming in Bhutan? – DW – 07/07/2022". dw.com. Retrieved 2 July 2024.
  43. ^ "Facebook post by Dzongkha Development Commission". Facebook. 8 September 2015.
  44. ^ Zam, Namgay (10 September 2015). "New words have added to our language". Facebook.
  45. ^ "Growing Up Gay in Bhutan". UNAIDS. 8 December 2015.
  46. ^ a b Leupold, John (1 March 2016). "To Be, or Not to Be, in Bhutan". The Gay & Lesbian Review.
  47. ^ "BKP pledges an inclusive government – KuenselOnline". www.kuenselonline.com.
  48. ^ Goswami, Bhupen (19 June 2019). "Bhutan Takes Huge Step Towards Decriminalising Homosexuality". APN News.
  49. ^ "Bhutan accepts its LGBTIQ community as NA decriminalizes Homosexuality".
  50. ^ a b Tshewang, Pema (24 May 2018). "Health workers lack skills to provide services to LGBT community, finds a study". Bhutan Broadcasting Service. Thimphu.
  51. ^ "About Lhak-Sam (BNP+)". lhaksam.org.bt.
  52. ^ Global encyclopedia of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ) history. Howard Chiang, Anjali R. Arondekar. Farmington Hills, Mich. 2019. ISBN 978-0-684-32554-5. OCLC 1080321952.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: others (link)
  53. ^ "Bhutan 2017 Human Rights Report" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 21 April 2018.
  54. ^ "Who can donate blood? | Blood Transfusion Service – Bhutan". Retrieved 16 March 2024.
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=LGBTQ_rights_in_Bhutan&oldid=1254180584"