Jump to content

Wikipedia:Requests for comment/User conduct/Archive: Difference between revisions

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→‎Archived disputes: filling in the blanks
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 17: Line 17:
| [[User:First Certifier|]], [[User:Second certifier|]]
| [[User:First Certifier|]], [[User:Second certifier|]]
| Outcome of the Rfc (agreement, arbitration, mediation, etc). -->
| Outcome of the Rfc (agreement, arbitration, mediation, etc). -->
|-
| [[Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Johnpacklambert|Johnpacklambert]]
| 12 December 2012
| excessive editing of the category namespace
| [[User:Purplebackpack89|Purplebackpack89]], [[User:Ephebi|Ephebi]]
| No users endorsed the certifier's position, only statements critical of the certifiers and the process received significant support.
|-
|-
|-
|-

Revision as of 00:01, 10 February 2013

This page is for archiving user conduct disputes listed on Wikipedia:Requests for comment. Archived disputes should not be added to. Disputes should be archived under any of the following circumstances:

  1. If no additional complaints are registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped.
  2. The parties to the dispute agree.
  3. The dispute proceeds to another method of dispute resolution, such as mediation or arbitration.

If the dispute is handled in mediation or arbitration, please make a note of where the dispute resolution process continued.

Archived disputes

Newer entries towards the top

Name Start date Description First two certifiers Notes
Johnpacklambert 12 December 2012 excessive editing of the category namespace Purplebackpack89, Ephebi No users endorsed the certifier's position, only statements critical of the certifiers and the process received significant support.
Rhode Island Red 2 21 November 2012 Civility, misuse of edit summaries, sopaboxing, biting the newcomers GeorgeLouis, Collect No consensus, closing admin suggested taking larger issues to arbitration
Bluerim 29 November 2012 Civility, edit warring, consensus Sjones23, JDC808 Closed due to inactivity; Bluerim's last edit was two months before closure
Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Niemti 01 November 2012 Incivility, ownership, Good articles, lack of edit summaries, Anita Sarkeesian article Bridies, GamerPro64 Topic ban from Anita Sarkeesian at ANI (
Apteva 30 November 2012 Concerns strongly asserted opinions about en dashes and the Manual of Style, and allegations of disruption Dicklyon, SMcCandlish Taken to WP:AN for action (diff; closing summary).
Darkstar1st 19 November 2012‎ To determine whether editor fails to "get the point" in discussions about article content. R-41, Kierzek Closing statement. Closure subsequently reverted, since it did not meet any of the criteria above.
RidjalA 3 November 2012 Concerns regarding possible personal attacks, Possible ownership, and disruptive behavior as a result of bias against the LDM church. Fordx12, Ajaxfiore Delisted due to inactivity
Paul Bedson 3 December 2012 Lack of compliance with verifiability and sourcing policies and guidelines, and original research. Mike Christie, Ealdgyth Unanimous consensus that the problems identified in the RfC exist. Paul Bedson was indefinitely blocked.
SchuminWeb 3 December 2012 Accountability for Administrative Actions Ironholds, GiantSnowman Several highly endorsed viewpoints. Referred to Arbitration.
HiLo48 30 October 2012 Civility, Use of offensive language Surturz, Skyring no consensus achieved.
Mmarque 19 October 2012 Personal attacks on several users Joel B. Lewis, ArthurPSmith no consensus due achieved.
Wikiwatcher1 6 August 2012 Copyright verification, disruption Moonriddengirl, We hope no consensus due to lack of community input
Kurmaa 24 August 2012 Disruptive interactions at talk pages Aeusoes1, Chaipau User indef blocked for sockpuppetry
Bittergrey 28 July 2012 Battleground mentality, COI/activism, off-wiki harassment of an editor WLU, Saedon Suspended due to Bittergrey being blocked for disruption on 30 July 2012
Offender9000 25 June 2012 Outing, violations of neutrality/weight and battleground-like conduct Daveosaurus, Stuartyeates No consensus achieved
Youreallycan 5 August 2012 Edit warring and personal attack Prioryman, Magog the Ogre Agreement. One month break followed by 3 month BLP restriction and 6 month 1RR and civility parole
Agent00f 12 May 2012 Talk page disruption Hasteur No consensus achieved.
TenPoundHammer 7 March 2012 Article deletion nominations Andy Dingley, Ruud Koot User offered to be more in line with community consensus
Vision Thing 20 March 2012 Biased editing Hipocrite, Lawrencekhoo Delisted due to inactivity
TBrandley 29 February 2012 Excessive article creation, disruption Logical Cowboy, JayJay Closed due to editor indef blocked
Kolins 10 January 2012 Potential editing against consensus and lack of discussion on talk pages. GiantSnowman, Drmies Closed after expiring without any response from Kolins
Fæ 25 January 2012 Various Delicious carbuncle, Aaron Brenneman No consensus was reached
DocKino 14 January 2012 alleged persistently uncivil edit summaries Mmyers1976, Dolphin DocKino has acknowledged that editing Wikipedia with frustration and anger is not conductive to a collaborative editing environment and will endeavor to refrain from said commentary in the future.
Hentzer 19 December 2011 lack of edit summaries and failure to respond to talk page inquires regarding use of edit summaries Nobody Ent, LibStar Subject never participated, no significant sanctionable activity
Shakehandsman 4 January 2012 user's application of NPOV and BLP Delicious carbuncle, Slp1 Suspended when user abruptly retired
GoodDay 4 December 2011 POV pushing Barryob, Snowded| Subject voluntarily agreed to restrictions and a mentorship program
Objectivist 14 October 2011 Soapboxing, using talk pages as a forum Lionelt, NYyankees51 Suspended when subject was indefinitely blocked
Badger Drink 8 November 2011 incivilty WereSpielChequers, Tom Morris Suspended when subject was indefinitely blocked
Alexsautographs 12 October 2011 Issues with unsourced biographies and behavior at WP:AFD Muboshgu, NY-13021 Some responses and views, no consensus, closed after long period of inactivity
Kiefer.Wolfowitz 8 October 2011 Alleged incivility, behavior regarding younger editors, and "accusations of plagiarism and copyright violation; lack of understanding of copyright" Worm That Turned, Demiurge1000 User agreed with uninvolved editors about some behavioral issues. No actions, bans, or other community sanctions. Closed by uninvolved admin.
La goutte de pluie 20 August 2011 Alleged issues involving WP:NPOV and WP:NOR OpenInfoForAll, Strange Passerby User resigned her administrator tools; affected articles placed under 1RR and semi-protection by the community in Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents/La goutte de pluie; RfC closed by uninvolved admin.
Willfults 27 July 2011 Allegations and concerns relating to activism, dishonest edit summaries, removal of sourced information, original research, and misrepresentation of sources. Ian.thomson, Tonicthebrown Responses; outside views; closed due to inactivity.
Drnhawkins 28 July 2011 Alledged original research and fake articles LadyofShalott, Dougweller Responses; outside views; closed per consensus.
Cirt 27 June 2011 Allegations and concerns related to promotionalism, activism, BLP violations, dishonesty, misrepresentation of sources, canvassing, etc. Jayen466, Cla68 Proceeded to arbitration.
Gwillhickers 9 June 2011 Alleged disruptive editing. Coemgenus, Carmarg4 Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Philip Baird Shearer 9 May 2011 Alleged disruptive editing. Parrot of Doom, SlimVirgin Closed by uninvolved administrator based on completed discussion and consensus reached by RFC participants (but not yet agreed to by the user).
Sempi 11 May 2011 Alleged disruptive editing. Richwales, Weazie Closed because of inactivity and cessation of editing by the user.
Raintheone 20 April 2011 Alleged disruptive editing. Jake Fuersturm, Fortdj33 Delisted due to agreed resolution.
Corbridge 6 April 2011 Alleged disruptive editing. Arbor8, Frank No response from subject; delisted due to inactivity.
Racepacket 2 22 March 2011 Alleged disruptive editing. Rschen7754, Imzadi1979 Responses; outside views; escalated to an arbitration request, which was initially declined; delisted after agreement to several restrictions and inactivity. Later proceeded to Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Racepacket to resolve remaining issues.
Bugapi 18 March 2011 Alleged disruptive editing. RadioFan, Tom Morris Outside views; closed by uninvolved user after Bugapi was indefinitely blocked.
Paralympiakos 4 March 2011 Alleged disruptive editing. Jfgslo, Tuoppi gm Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Tenmei 2 March 2011 Alleged battleground mentality and disruptive talk page editing. Qwyrxian, Bobthefish2 Responses; outside views; closed by participant in the RfC/U.
Geo Swan 15 February 2011 Alleged ongoing creation of pages not suitable for Wikipedia. Fram, Cunard Responses; outside views; delisted due to agreed resolution and inactivity.
AlexCovarrubias 2 13 February 2011 Alleged disregard for editorial discussion and consensus-building. Maunus, Missionary Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Bidgee 13 February 2011 Alleged uncivil behaviour generally, biting newcomers and misuse of userpage. Jeffro77, danjel Closed by agreement of certifiers after retirement of Bidgee.
Timneu22 9 February 2011 Alleged poor quality new pages patrol and unresponsiveness to attempts to communicate. Kudpung, Jayen466 Outside views; delisted due to agreement and stated retirement of Timneu22.
Lihaas 27 January 2011 Alleged disruptive editing. O Fenian, RepublicanJacobite Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Sfan00 IMG 25 January 2011 Alleged disruption in reviewing media files. Andy Dingley, RexxS Responses; outside views; delisted per motion to close and due to inactivity.
MickMacNee 26 December 2010 Alleged disruption at AFD and DRV, and alleged incivility. Cirt, Mjroots Responses; outside views; delisted due to agreed resolution and inactivity.
YellowMonkey 23 November 2010 Alleged poor block and failure to respond to community concerns. HJ Mitchell, Wehwalt Responses; outside views; escalated to an arbitration request, which was declined; delisted due to inactivity.
WeijiBaikeBianji 22 November 2010 Alleged edit warring, gaming, and a possible conflict of interest. VsevolodKrolikov, Woodsrock Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Nyttend 5 November 2010 Questions about use of WP:REVDEL. SandyGeorgia, Elen of the Roads Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Hullaballoo Wolfowitz 5 November 2010 Alleged wikibullying and possible wikistalking. Dekkappai, TenPoundHammer No response from subject; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Xanderliptak 24 October 2010 It is alleged that there has been persistent tendentiousness and ownership related to a conflict of interest in the use of images. Moonriddengirl, Roux Responses; outside views; matter proceeded to AN where sanctions were imposed.
BlueRobe (2nd RfC/U) 25 September 2010 It is alleged that there has been incessant incivility. The Four Deuces, Fifelfoo User was blocked indefinitely for ongoing uncivil editing a few days after the RfC/U was filed.
Milogardner 15 September 2010 It is alleged that there have been persistent problems including original research, conflict of interest, disruptive editing and ownership. David Eppstein, AnnekeBart Outside view; response; delisted due to inactivity; escalated to ANI where the community imposed a topic ban on Milogardner.
Gavin.collins (3rd RfC/U) 14 September 2010 It is alleged that there has been persistent, tenacious editing and other unhelpful discussion behavior in policy/guideline discussions about notability and other topics. Mike Cline, DGG Outside views; delisted due to inactivity and motion to close.
KnowIG 12 September 2010 It is alleged that there are various problems including incivility, personal attacks, edit-warring, ownership of articles. TreasuryTag, Armbrust Response; outside view; delisted due to inactivity. In October, subject was blocked for 1 month.
Mjroots 3 September 2010 Dispute concerning AfD conduct. MickMacNee, AKMask Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Pumpie (2nd RfC/U) 18 August 2010 Dispute on continuous creation of badly translated articles. Cplakidas, Yngvadottir Outside view; no response; delisted due to inactivity.
Slrubenstein 16 August 2010 Dispute relating to WP:NPA. Noloop, Fences and windows Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Jimmy McDaniels 15 August 2010 Long-running dispute related to WP:COI and WP:NPOV primarily on Jason Leopold, also Truthout. Yworo, Gsp8181 Escalated to ANI when Jimmy McDaniels would not agree to stop editing the article; community imposed topic ban.
TMC1982 1 August 2010 Dispute over massive number of articles, templates, categories and lists created by the user. Weaponbb7, Staxringold Outside view; no response; delisted ue to inactivity.
Pmanderson 26 July 2010 Civility issues OpenFuture, marknutley Responses to summaries, closed due to inactivity after being open for over 5 weeks. General consensus seems to be that Pmanderson needs to change the way he interacts with other users, and obey WP:CIVIL and WP:NPA.
Sven70 21 July 2010 Dispute relating to WP:NPA, WP:NLT, and canvassing users on the same issue. Netalarm, Xavexgoem Matter proceeded to ANI; Sven70 was blocked indefinitely.
Blablaaa 21 July 2010 Dispute relating to WP:DISRUPT, WP:CIVIL, WP:CONSENSUS and WP:NPOV on various military history articles. EyeSerene, Kirill Lokshin User retired while a request for arbitration was being considered. Shortly after retiring, user was indef blocked (rationale).
Teeninvestor 17 July 2010 Dispute relating to WP:V and WP:DUE. Nev1, Gun Powder Ma Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity. Subject was blocked for 3 weeks for violating interaction restriction.
Mk5384 25 June 2010 Dispute relating to WP:CIV and WP:NPA. OberRanks, JzG Matter proceeded to ANI; restrictions were imposed.
Jclemens 11 June 2010 Abuse of rollback privileges, behavior unbecoming of an admin. Snottywong, Wolfkeeper Responses; outside views; delisted due to motion to close.
Ryan kirkpatrick 1 June 2010 Dispute relating to WP:V, WP:NOR and other policies.. O Fenian, RepublicanJacobite Outside view; no response; delisted due to inactivity. Clear consensus that Ryan kirkpatrick's editing is problematic. During this RfC/U, Ryan kirkpatrick was blocked for sockpuppetry.
Chelo61 26 May 2010 Dispute relating to WP:V, WP:NOR and other policies. Phearson, Xymmax Outside views; no response; delisted due to inactivity.
Jamen Somasu 23 May 2010 A dispute relating to WP:POINT, WP:GAMING, and especially WP:CIVIL. Killervogel5, The Rambling Man Response; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Handicapper 7 May 2010 A dispute over policy guidelines and marking edits as minor in topic area "Thoroughbred racing". Gnevin, Cgoodwin Consensus that Handicapper has serious ownership issues, and is editing inappropriately - marking major edits as minor, and failing to abide by consensus. Should Handicapper fail to address these issues voluntarily, an administrator may impose blocks, or the issue may be escalated to an an appropriate noticeboard for community attention so that restrictions or a ban may be imposed. If necessary, a request for arbitration may also be filed if these methods do not resolve the issue.
B9 hummingbird hovering 1 May 2010 It is alleged that this editor has persistently and blatantly misused and misrepresented sources in their contributions here over several years, despite many requests from other editors to change their behaviour. Beeblebrox, PlainJain Matter proceeded to ANI; user indef-blocked.
Lar 30 April 2010 A dispute regarding whether Lar should be acting as an uninvolved admin at climate change requests for enforcement William M. Connolley, Polargeo Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Jagged 85 21 April 2010 It is alleged that this editor has persistently and blatantly misused and misrepresented sources in their contributions here over several years, despite many requests from other editors to change their behaviour. Syncategoremata, SteveMcCluskey Responses; outside views; closed by agreement.
BQZip01 9 April 2010 Long standing dispute between this editor and Hammersoft. TransporterMan, Juliancolton Responses; outside view; delisted due to inactivity.
Ash 5 April 2010 It is alleged that contrary to policy and guidelines, Ash has improperly added citations which reference facts that are not present in the sources to multiple articles, including at least one BLP. Delicious carbuncle, Jack Merridew User stopped editing Wikipedia. Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Prestonmcconkie 12 March 2010 It is alleged that this editor is frequently offensive and insulting via edit summaries, and has been entirely non-responsive to queries about this from several editors over several months. Asdfg12345, Dilip_rajeev No responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
PCPP 2 March 2010 It is alleged that PCPP behaves outside Wikipedia norms in editing pages related to Falun Gong and the Chinese Communist Party, including deleting vast amounts of content, failing to engage in meaningful discussion, restoring information that has no sources, ignoring consensus or ongoing discussion on talk pages, accusing others of bad faith, etc. Asdfg12345, Dilip_rajeev Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Newman Luke 24 February 2010 It is alleged that Newman Luke ignores various wikipedia policies and consensus and unilaterally makes significant and disputed changes to Judaism and Biblical articles against existing consensus. Avi, Debresser Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Cush (2nd) 22 February 2010 It is alleged that Cush has been in blatant disregard of WP:CIVIL and several other related violations. Weaponbb7, Lisa Outside views; no response; delisted due to inactivity.
Michael H 34 25 January 2010 It is alleged that Michael H 34, while civil, has shown longterm evidence of advocacy and disruptive editing on articles related to fathers' and men's rights. Slp1, WLU Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Wuhwuzdat 15 January 2010 It is alleged that Wuhwuzdat improperly gave an "only warning" to a user acting in good faith, refused to discuss or accept other user comments on the scenario, and has not taken long-term advice on civilty and avoiding biting other users. RexxS, Taelus Outside views given; delisted due to inactivity and motion to close on talk page.
Asgardian 24 February 2010 It is alleged that Asgardian exerts ownership over articles, edit wars, is incivil, purposely uses incomplete edit summaries and sometimes edits from IP addresses to evade blocks. BOZ, Dream Focus Proceeded to arbitration.
Doncram 4 February 2010 Article ownership, edit warring, several months of disputes Elkman, Orlady No outside views or comments; minimal discussion. Closed due to inactivity and lack of outside interest.
Mafia godfather 11 January 2010 It is alleged that Mafia godfather is editing tendentitiously with regard to articles concerning the sovereignty of Taiwan, Due to said dispute, said editor has also allegedly engaged in violations of other policies and guidelines. Ngchen, T-1000 Responses; outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Glkanter 22 December 2009 It is alleged that Glkanter edits tendentiously, is apparently not here to help build an encyclopedia, disruptively edits including driving away productive contributors, and treats editing as a personal battle misusing his user and user talk pages to chronicle his fight and disparage other users. Rick Block, Dicklyon Responses; outside view; delisted due to inactivity.
ChildofMidnight 21 December 2009 Failure to AGF, to be civil, to use dispute resolution (see summary) Bigtimepeace, John Carter Somewhat lengthy, see summary.
Logicus (2nd) 14 December 2009 POV pushing, adding original research, responds to any discussion with "wall of text" responses SteveMcCluskey, Finell Logicus indef sitebanned via WP:AN.
CarolineWH 25 November 2009 It is alleged that CarolineWH has repeatedly failed to withdraw or substantially correct or apologise for uncivil mischaracterizations of other users; possible other issues for comment under policies WP:MEAT and WP:OUTING. Paularblaster, Schrandit Proceed to ANI; user indef-blocked.
Dbachmann 18 November 2009 It is alleged that Dbachmann has misused rollback and protection in an edit dispute with an IP at Telugu language and refused to conduct meaningful discussion with at least three previously uninvolved editors on his talk page at User_talk:Dbachmann#Telugu. Doug, Rd232 Use of sysop tools bore up under scrutiny. The community, in giving feedback to all parties, strongly feels that Dbachmann's contributions are highly valuable and hopes that he will continue as time permits. Closed early at the request of participants. Rd232 apologised to Dbachmann for the resulting drama.
Orderinchaos 17 November 2009 Restoration of unsourced info at WP:BLP, and an unblock of another user that was blocked for same. Cirt, Coffee Closed by nominator, per positive resolution. [1]
Rjanag 4 November 2009 It is alleged that Rjanag has engaged in a pattern of serious, persistent misconduct: untruths, incivility, personal attacks, profanity, wikihounding, bad faith, bullying, edit warring, gaming the system, hidden conflict of interest, and admin tools misuse. This RfC/U follows the advice given by arbitrators when the relevant request for arbitration was declined. Epeefleche, NBeale Delisted due to relative inactivity. Weak evidence to substantiate strong claims - no consequence beyond a reminder needed. Rjanag is reminded to refrain from making unacceptable commentary, albeit, snippy or obscene, so that he conducts himself in a manner that befits his admin position.
Cush 4 November 2009 It is alleged that Cush has consistently been uncivil and refused to assume good faith, and has explicitly stated that religious editors should not be allowed to edit articles related to religious subjects because of a perceived conflict of interest. Lisa, SkyWriter Outside view; no response; delisted due to inactivity.
NancyHeise 27 October 2009 It is alleged that NancyHeise has contributed to the battleground mentality that currently exists at Talk:Catholic Church. She has displayed article ownership tendencies, has failed to assume good faith, has been incivil, and has pushed a POV. Karanacs, Pmanderson Mixed responses and views; delisted due to inactivity & by agreement.
Racepacket 13 October 2009 It is alleged that Racepacket has shown a pattern of tendentious edits, ownership, and flawed concepts of point of view and consensus in regards to University of Miami and related articles in Category:University of Miami. Ryulong, PassionoftheDamon Mixed responses and views; delisted due to inactivity and agreement to close.
Sarah777 (2nd) 7 October 2009 Sarah777 has been acting inappropiately with respect to British and Irish roads. They have appeared to show bias (possibly unintionally), ignored normal methods of forming consensus, engaged in move/edit warring, has been disruptive, has failed to ensure her facts are correct and has not been civil. Dpmuk, Thryduulf Mixed responses and views; delisted due to inactivity.
Megistias 21 September 2009 This user has harassed in a number of occasions, has been pushing POV in Albanian related articles, has assumed bad faith and did not respond to Third Opinion. Future Perfect at Sunrise, AnnaFabiano Delisted due to inactivity; no outside views.
A Nobody 20 September 2009 Concerns about A Nobody's conduct in various forums of discussion and debate on Wikipedia and his methods of engaging in those discussions. MBisanz, Lar Outside views, no response; delisted by motion to close.
Benjiboi 26 August 2009 Concerns about Benjiboi's pattern of editing which have effectively excluded other editors from changing Wikipedia:Paid editing and participating in discussions at Wikipedia talk:Paid editing. Will Beback, TeaDrinker Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Noloop 11 August 2009 User continues accusing others of stalking, trolling, and possible socking. Abce2, WebHamster Proceeded to arbitration.
Keepscases 10 August 2009 User appears not to be here to build an encyclopedia, in that the user appears to be excessively uncivil and continues to disrupt, soapbox, and bully candidate atheists at RfA, effectuating a chilling effect on atheistic potential candidates. Jeff G., Mythdon Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Bishonen 3 3 August 2009 Abetting and concealing admin sock-puppetry of benefit to her stance in a dispute; refusal to provide good explanation; conduct as an admin to other users (civility, personal attacks, bad faith, consensus). Xavexgoem, FT2 Outside views, no response; delisted by motion to close.
Sbakuria 31 July 2009 Disruptive editing, refusal to discuss with others. Rtdixon86, PhilKnight Outside view, no response; user indefinitely blocked.
Aitias 2 30 July 2009 Continuing the pattern of behavior that led up to his first RfC and his ArbCom case. Acalamari, Majorly Proceeded to ArbCom desysop motion.
RetroS1mone 25 July 2009 Disruptive editing and unsubstantiated accusations. RobinHood70, Tekaphor Response (later removed by subject) and outside view; delisted due to inactivity.
194x144x90x118 20 July 2009 User edits tendentiously on Talk:DreamHost and elsewhere. Scjessey, Dayewalker Proceeded to arbitration.
Wdl1961 13 July 2009 User has long and persistent history of violating consensus, talk, 3RR, bias, Disrupt, Sign. No constructive or coherent engagement on talk pages. Scheinwerfermann, CrazyInSane Delisted due to inactivity. Consensus that Wdl1961 needs to work on improving his communication and make greater efforts to participate in talk page discussion, particularly for controversial changes he makes.
Frei Hans 6 July 2009 User makes flippant accusations of vandalism and sockpuppetry and refuses to observe consensus Papa November, Mangoe User indefinitely blocked for by an administrator for making disruptive unfounded accusations.
Mgillfr 2 July 2009 User refuses to observe what has been determined by consensus Rschen7754, Davemeistermoab Response and outside view; delisted due to inactivity.
Viriditas 29 June 2009 User engaged in extensive violations of WP:Civil, WP:Wikihounding, WP:Disruptive editing, WP:HUSH and others. Mosedschurte, Yachtsman1 Outside view and no response; delisted due to inactivity.
Friday 26 June 2009 Continually making the atmosphere uncomfortable and unpleasant for editors, and abuse of admin tools. Majorly, Juliancolton Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Docu 17 June 2009 User refuses to use a signature with a link and timestamp despite multiple requests to modify this behavior. Nihonjoe, Cirt RFC closed as resolved.
Uruk2008 12 June 2009 Poor references and disruptive edits, no response to multiple warnings and bans. BenRG, Enric Naval Outside views, no response; delisted due to inactivity.
Born2cycle 4 June 2009 Long-term wikilawyering. Tedder, Dbratland Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Montana's Defender 19 May 2009 User refuses to discuss... pretty much anything with anyone for any reason. Beeblebrox, EEMIV User blocked briefly for making threats. No response; no outside views.
Stilltim 13 May 2009 User is creating numerous (hundreds) disruptive content forks. Ironholds, Grodonrox24 Response and outside view; delisted due to inactivity.
Either way 7 May 2009 He has consistantly hounded many editors that he meets. Download, Neutralhomer Delisted by motion to close; consensus to dismiss as frivolous.
Tennis expert 27 April 2009 He has edit warred and been disruptive to the spirit of cooperation and good faith of Wikipedia. Alonsornunez, Mendaliv Delisted per motion to close following Tennis expert's invocation of WP:RTV.
Collect 15 Apr 2009 Collect is a tendentious editor with a long history of edit warring and gaming the system/using Wikipedia policies and guidelines in bad faith. Phoenix of9, Dicklyon Request for arbitration rejected. User warned and restricted.
Grant.Alpaugh 20 Apr 2009 Abuse of editing privileges, ie WP: WAR; WP:EVADE; WP:SOCK Nja247, Grsz11 User blocked indefinitely per WP:SOCK
JzG 3 4 Apr 2009 JzG has used administrative tools with respect to articles with which he was involved, and with respect to editors with whom he was in dispute. JzG has ignored or rejected comments and requests regarding this, and has denied improper use of tools. Abd, Durova Mixed views; delisted by motion to close. Proceeded to arbitration.
Badagnani 24 March 2009 Constantly violating Wikipedia policies and choosing to criticize the editor instead of the edits, refuses to cooperate when editing and only asks to discuss regarding the edits, which he almost never participates in. Eugene2x, Caspian blue Outside views and no response; delisted due to inactivity. Badagnani urged to find a different way of handling disputes.
Duke53 2 16 Mar 2009 Requests that a user remove certain user page content that reflected a past dispute was met by resistance. Hoopsphanatic, Alanyst User who resisted initial requests conceded to add NOINDEX template to user page to avoid search engine; requesting user deemed this acceptable.
DrKiernan 11 Mar 2009 DrKiernan unilaterally downgraded at least 267 pages from A-class, marking most edits as minor, during a period when Community-wide discussion on A-class was (and is) ongoing. Physchim62, Hiding Resolved: assessment changes that involve grades above C-class should not be marked as minor edits.
Ryulong 2 3 Mar 2009 Abuse of blocking and rollback privileges. Tiptoety, Hersfold Proceeded to arbitration.
Andrewjlockley 23 Feb 2009 Edit warring, over enthusiasm, abuse of references, POV pushing in and around geoengineering and global warming topics. William M. Connolley, Awickert Response and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Aitias 20 Feb 2009 Incivility, edit warring and possible misuse of admin tools. Majorly, Acalamari RFC-initiators agreed to close the RFC as resolved.
Dicklyon 2 11 Feb 2009 Pervasive incivility and hostile profanity, tendentious editing, edit warring, assumptions of bad faith regarding other users' motivations, unevidenced accusations of misconduct of others, and lack of responsiveness to community feedback. James Cantor (previously MarionTheLibrarian, Hfarmer Response and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Giano II 16 Jan 2009 Prolonged incivility, sockpuppetry, accusing other users of misconduct. Mackensen, Durova Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Cambios 7 Jan 2009 Prolonged incivility, sockpuppetry, accusing other users of misconduct. Patton, Stifle Responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Mattisse 3 4 Jan 2009 Conduct with regards to FAC/GAN/DYK, and accusations of sockpuppetry. Casliber, Lar Proposals made on going forward; delisted due to inactivity.
Pixelface 30 Dec 2008 Pixelface, in participating in discussions regarding Wikipedia policy on fiction topics, engages in an editing style and discussion style that is uncivil and disruptive to the encyclopedia, which does not help in establishing a consensus for how these topics should be dealt with. Masem, Protonk. Responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Law Lord 21 Dec 2008 Self-filed RFC with questions on personal attacks and abuse of admin tools. Self-filed by Law Lord. Proposal to close enacted - by agreement of involved users (as well as uninvolved users). RFC closed as resolved.
Gavin.collins 2 5 Dec 2008 Accusations of conflict of interest, disparaging remarks, and hostile tone. Drilnoth, BOZ Agreement to a 3-month break from editing articles around other involved editors.
Pé de Chinelo 29 Nov 2008 Removing references and edit warring on video game articles MuZemike, chocobogamer, GamerPro64 User blocked indefinitely at WP:AN.
EmilEikS 25 Nov 2008 Issues with User:EmilEikS regarding overall overt and implied behavior which is contentious and disruptive to the project. Wildhartlivie, Momoricks EmilEikS retired from Wikipedia on 1 December 2008.
Thunderbird2 21 Nov 2008 Repeated disruptive POINTY editing. Fnagaton, Greg L Delisted due to inactivity; no response; one outside view.
jmh649 15 Nov 2008 The main problem is Doc James' article ownership and the personal attacks and editwarring that accompany it. Vannin, Vaoverland Delisted due to inactivity; parties to discuss content on article talk page.
Slrubenstein 10 Nov 2008 Made an unblock without any attempt to contact the blocking admin or to have the block reviewed first. Charles Matthews, Jehochman RFC-initiators agreed to close the RFC as resolved.
Privatemusings 6 Nov 2008 Disruption of the community by failing to accept consensus. MBisanz, Lar Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Roux 30 Oct 2008 Incivil and abusive behaviour, on both talk pages and in edit summaries, tendenitious editing, refusal to cooperate in discussion. G2bambino, Mayalld Editing restrictions imposed per this RFC, and G2bambino blocked.
Blackworm 25 Oct 2008 Ongoing problems related to Blackworm's behaviour at the Circumcision article and related articles. Coppertwig, Jakew Delisted due to inactivity; no outside views.
Hemanshu 21 Oct 2008 That Hemanshu has failed to respond to inquiries about his edits. MBisanz, Jaysweet User stopped editing on 7 November 2008.
G2bambino 16 Oct 2008 Incivility, POV pushing, refusal to co-operate in discussions Roux, Mayalld Editing restrictions imposed.
Matt reltub 7 Oct 2008 Has assumed aggressive and attacking behavior, has made unwarranted accusations of Meat Puppetry, and has attempted to take control of the article without coming to a dispute resolution. Rabicante, Mayalld All three editors stopped editing Wikipedia. Parties certifying dispute were blocked for sockpuppetry before departure.
GabrielVelasquez 6 Oct 2008 Has engaged in out-of-the-blue personal attacks, failed to assume good faith, tossed around several accusations of sockpuppetry and in general he is prone to aggressive, disruptive behaviour. Cyclopia, Icalanise Delisted due to inactivity. Clear consensus that although GabrielVelasquez makes good faith attempts to improve the project, he needs to spend more time thinking about how his words and tone may be taken by others - to avoid repeatedly coming into conflict with others.
Marvin Shilmer 29 Sep 2008 Bias against Jehovah's Witnesses, incivility and condescension, claims of 'character assassination', ignoring Wikipedia guidelines regarding archived articles in User subpages Jeffro77 RFC withdrawn, resolved at Talk.
Expeditionradio 28 Sep 2008 Disruptive and single-subject editing of articles on Automatic link establishment, violations of WP:COI, WP:SPA, WP:OWN, WP:LUC, WP:CIVIL, WP:VANDAL Manway, Tallaeus Editor stopped editing on October 2 2008.
Alleichem 25 Sep 2008 Disruptive and single-subject editing of articles on God's name, violations of WP:NPOV, WP:V, WP:NOR, WP:UNDUE, WP:CIVIL LisaLiel User banned as repeat sockpuppet.
Davidruben 23 Sep 2008 Davidruben promoted WP:MEDRS to guideline over well-argued objections of several editors. He then took sides in the resulting dispute by reverting to the version of the page he prefers and protecting the revert. Paul gene, Colonel Warden Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Davegnz 18 Sep 2008 User showing long-standing pattern of behaviours inconsistent with a communal, collegiate environment, including incivility, threatened and actual disruption, unwillingness to abide by consensus, and sense of ownership of material. Rlandmann, Askari Mark Editor stopped editing on 24 October 2008 - should he return and continue engaging in the problematic conduct brought up in this RFC, he may be sanctioned accordingly.
Kainaw 17 Sep 2008 Incivility, assumption of bad faith. Philcha, Sjakkalle Response and outside view; delisted due to inactivity.
Roberttheman2008 11 Sep 2008 User showing blatant disregard for Wikipedia policies and guidelines via making threats and incivility during an AfD. MuZemike, JuJube Further disruption will lead to an indef block; Roberttheman2008 stopped editing September 21 2008.
Tony1 8 Sep 2008 Unlinking dates without appropriate discussion, in defiance of requests to temporarily hold off. UC_Bill, Sapphic Tony1's edits accepted as correct.
Goingoveredge 31 Aug 2008 Reverting and deleting information without appropriate discussion. Princhest, Roadahead Parties warned not to edit war, Goingoveredge warned not to make personal attacks.
Future Perfect at Sunrise 30 Aug 2008 Issues with behavior and policy interpretations, primarily centered around images Sumoeagle179, John Future Perfect at Sunrise warned to follow WP:CIVIL and WP:NPA.
Particleman24 30 Aug 2008 No understanding of policy such as WP:V and WP:NPOV. Yngvarr, Treelo Particleman24 stopped editing on 27 August 2008.
Sceptre 2 28 Aug 2008 Self-filed RFC. Sceptre, MBisanz Sceptre retired on 29 August 2008.
Majorly 27 Aug 2008 Self-filed RFC. Balloonman, MBisanz Majorly requested desysopping on 2 September 2008, and was desysopped by a steward at meta.
Sarumio 18 Aug 2008 Ignores consensus in making mass edits to articles related to football clubs Dweller, The Rambling Man Delisted due to inactivity.
Fasach Nua 2 15 Aug 2008 Disruptive edits and edit warring in the 'Notable Player' sections of 'National Football Team' articles. Aaron_carass, SoWhy Mixed outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
InternetHero 14 Aug 2008 Personal attacks, edit-warring, vandalism and undue weight/sourcing problems. But user appears to in good faith believe his edits are neutral. DigitalC, Mark Chovain InternetHero has made no edits for three weeks, and appears to be retired.
JJL 12 Aug 2008 An editor who has a tendency to be disruptive, uncivil, and unwilling to compromise. Omnedon, Huwmanbeing Delisted due to inactivity.
Elonka 1 Aug 2008 Concerns about the management of editing conditions. ChrisO, Ned Scott See Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Elonka#Conclusion
MAL01159 29 Jul 2008 A disruptive and tendentious single purpose account. MAL01159 has disputed every source provided by other editors, but has not provided any source to back up their own position. SheffieldSteel, Kingturtle MAL01159 is warned about making edits contrary to consensus, and urged to read the policies on original research, consensus, WP:V, and WP:NPOV. Further disruption will result in a block.
Psychobillypolice 25 Jul 2008 New user who has revert-warred, made uncivil comments and mild threats, and responds to constructive criticisms with hostility. IllaZilla, JD554 Psychobillypolice stopped editing on 25 July 2008.
Posturewriter 20 Jul 2008 Long-term tendentious and disruptive editing, personal attacks and bad-faith statements. Gordonofcartoon, EdJohnston Posturewriter is reminded of the WP:COI policy, and asked to avoid editing articles that fall under that scope for him. Further COI issues may result in a topic ban.
Bogdangiusca 19 Jul 2008 Moved unilaterally a page whose name has been very controversial, against the Wikipedia policy. AKoan, Kuaichik Case deferred to mediation
Exidor 17 Jul 2008 Refusal to follow consensus, personal attacks, incivility. Tedickey, Karnesky Exidor warned to be more civil.
Florentino floro 17 Jul 2008 For repeated violation of notability, relevance, and npov guidelines. TheCoffee, Cma Florentino floro warned in regards to trivial additions, behavioral tendencies, and long messages.
Kirill Lokshin 16 Jul 2008 Self-filed RFC/U, primarily regarding arbitration-related conduct. Kirill Lokshin, John Carter Kirill's actions are considered satisfactory - it is hoped that lessons are learned for the future.
Cleo123 10 Jul 2008 Disruptive, incivil commentary on others, possibly willful misapplication of policies and guidelines, little apparent interest in seeking consensus. Tendancer, Ottava Rima Cleo123 warned about BLP reversions, encouraged to use WP:BLP/N. Cleo123 hasn't edited since July 10.
Alastair Haines 7 Jul 2008 Refusal to follow consensus, personal attacks, incivility. Rushyo, L'Aquatique Alastair Haines warned to be civil and not to make legal threats; case sent to arbitration.
Rvaste 6 Jul 2008 In Leonard Feeney, persistent posting of same version, no response to attempts at communication. Jnestorius, Garion96 Rvaste indefinitely blocked.
GoRight 4 Jul 2008 Disruptive editing, BLP editing, Harassment. William M. Connolley, Raul654 All involved users in the dispute advised to engage in appropriate conduct. GoRight subject to a community sanction.
Marburg72 3 Jul 2008 Problems with WP:3RR, WP:COIN, WP:OR and general refusal to accept information which conflicts with his own ideas. David Trochos, Dougweller Marburg72 blocked for 24 hours. Indefinitely blocked on 1 July 2011 for abusing multiple accounts.
Dorftrottel 23 Jun 2008 Self-filed Rfc/U, following considerable criticism about civility. Dorftrottel, Casliber Dorftrottel cautioned regarding civility, warned about future sanctions
CarolSpears 22 Jun 2008 WP:COPYVIO Shoemaker's Holiday, Durova CarolSpears indefinitely blocked after subsequent ANI report.
Esimal 18 Jun 2008 Personal attacks, edit warring, POV pushing. The Evil Spartan, Cuchullain Esimal retired from Wikipedia on 18 June 2008.
Greg_L 4 Jun 2008 Constant incivility, disregard for consensus, votemongering, vote stacking. Omegatron, Thunderbird2 Both parties given substantial feedback on their conduct - delisted due to relative inactivity.
Tom_davy 23 May 2008 User edits without communication, only reverting and undo edits of others. Dchall1, Boogalouie Tom davy stopped editing on 25 June 2008, proposed remedy adopted should he return.
Zeuspitar 23 May 2008 Incivility, disruptive editing, personal attacks, legal threats, using Wikipedia as a battlefield. Wikidas, Shruti14 Zeuspitar stopped editing on 3 July 2008.
TheNautilus/I'clast 21 May 2008 Abuse of multiple accounts. Refusal to abide by content policies and respect consensus, edit warring. TimVickers, Fyslee TheNautilus stopped editing on 3 June 2008; I'clast stopped editing on 23 May 2008.
Lilith2396 21 May 2008 Constant insults and attacks on other users. Sockpuppetry. TallNapoleon, Idag Per Wikipedia:Suspected sock puppets/Spinoza1111, Lilith2396 was blocked for 2 months by EdJohnston. He has stopped editing since.
Abtract 20 May 2008 Edit warring, incivility, gaming the system, personal attacks. Collectonian, Arcayne Abtract was blocked a couple of times, and then stopped editing on 23 June 2008.
LahoreKid 14 May 2008 WP:CIVIL, WP:BLP NEDian, WWGB Delisted due to inactivity; LahoreKid hasn't edited since June 1
69.121.221.174 6 May 2008 Incivility/Edit-warring Idag, Ethan a adawe Anon stopped editing on 18 June 2008.
VoABot II 5 May 2008 Blind bot reverting of new users Hesperian, Soxred93 Issue resolved.
Yorkshirian 5 May 2008 Incivility/Edit-warring MRSC, Jza84 Proceeded to arbitration.
Guido den Broeder 30 Apr 2008 Disruption of Wikipedia via COI and EL violations and wikilawyering Fram, Scarian Guido den Broeder blocked for 48 hours by Davidruben.
Femmina 27 Apr 2008 Disruptive NPOV edits on iPhone Atama, Phooto Delisted due to inactivity. No response, no outside views.
Justinm1978 27 Apr 2008 Disruption of Wikipedia via POV pushing and disregard for consensus. Miranda, Allstarecho Consensus to dismiss as premature.
Wageslave 24 Apr 2008 Disruptive NPOV edits on several articles. Frvernchanezzz, John.n-IRL Wageslave stopped editing on 15 May 2008.
Ed Fitzgerald 22 Apr 2008 Disregard for consensus, primarily regarding formatting/style. Clarityfiend, Tagishsimon Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
Cebactokpatop 16 Apr 2008 Tendentious edits, incivility, refusal to assume good faith and personal attacks by SPA on John Zizioulas page, leading to page protection and breakdown of informal mediation (twice). Seminarist, Fr Lev Delisted due to inactivity; no outside views.
RobJ1981 14 Apr 2008 Harassment, WP:AGF, WP:CIVIL, WP:POINT and WP:OWN McJeff, Angrymansr RobJ1981 blocked for 1 month by Hesperian.
Tango 13 Apr 2008 Questionable block of MONGO, pattern of poor judgement in use of certain admin tools Nwwaew, Jehochman Proceeded to arbitration
Bardcom 2 Apr 2008 Persistent POV edits to remove geographic terminology he objects to. Tb, Secisek RFC-initiators formally agreed to avoid continuation of dispute and to close the RFC.
Seeyou 27 Mar 2008 Incivility/Edit-warring/Accusations of sock-puppetry Jéské Couriano, Ronz Delisted due to inactivity; no outside views.
Pedant17 11 Mar 2008 Edit-warring RJC, BCST2001 Consensus to dismiss as premature and certifiers advised to attempt negotiation, Rfc on article content or mediation.
75.47.x.x 3 Mar 2008 Edit warring, incivility. Evil saltine , NE2 RFC archived due to inactivity.
JzG2 2 Mar 2008 Multiple violations of (editing, decorum, admin) policy Cla68, Neil Proceeded to arbitration
WNDL42 28 Feb 2008 Incivility, disruptive editing, content disputes Jefffire, Kww Consensus to dismiss as premature and certifiers advised to attempt negotiation, Rfc on article content or mediation.
DemolitionMan 26 Feb 2008 Persistent edit warring and disruption at Indian Rebellion of 1857 Ronnotel, Slatersteven User topic banned on British Raj articles for 2 months per ANI thread
IZAK 24 Feb 2008 Alleged violations of WP:CIVIL, WP:NPA, WP:AGF & WP:OWN Bstone, Soxred93 RfC closed so that mediation may be attempted
Skyring 22 Feb 2008 Tendentious editing. Wm, Eyedubya Delisted due to inactivity.
Strider12 20 Feb 2008 Tendentious editing. MastCell, Phyesalis Proceeded to arbitration.
77.128.196.58 15 Feb 2008 IP range edit-warring against consensus. Psantora, Data Fever Delisted due to inactivity.
Mantanmoreland 12 Feb 2008 Sockpuppetry. SirFozzie, Durova Proceeded to ArbCom; see final decision.
Quizimodo 11 Feb 2008 Incivility. Gazzster, GoodDay Delisted due to inactivity. Conflict subsided after Quizimodo stopped editing on 13 February 2008.
Skipsievert 9 Feb 2008 POV-pushing and not cooperating with other editors. Isenhand , Luxaquitaine Delisted due to inactivity.
Cumulus Clouds 9 Feb 2008 Various disputed edits. BQZip01, Johntex Delisted due to inactivity.
Archtransit 4 Feb 2008 Dispute with unblocks and blocks Fut.Perf., Bellwether_BC Achtransit was desysopped following evidence that he had been abusing multiple accounts, see ArbCom statement.
Muscovite99 23 Jan 2008 Issues. Frjohnwhiteford , Miyokan Delisted due to inactivity.
81.9.61.227 23 Jan 2008 Revert-warring at Thelema article from multiple IPs. Dan , Thiebes Delisted due to inactivity.
MPF 16 Jan 2008 Naming conflicts regarding plant common names. Rkitko , MrDarwin Delisted due to inactivity. Conflict subsided after MPF took an extended wikibreak.
BigGabriel555 13 Jan 2008 tendentious editing, disruption, edit warring, WP:OWN Pepemar2, SamEV Issues settled through negotiation, apology and agreement.
Fasach Nua 10 Jan 2008 Targeting images for deletion with faulty reasoning. Edokter, Sceptre Delisted due to inactivity.
Whig 3 8 Jan 2008 Resumed problematic edits after indefblock overturned. Vanished User, Filll Dispute endorsed by some editors; RfC considered inappropriate/unnecessary by others.
V-Dash 8 Jan 2008 Disruption, incivility, disregarding consensus. Jéské Couriano, Friday V-Dash was indefblocked by Friday on 14 January 2008 after continued disruption and incivility (block notice).
R. fiend 5 Jan 2008 Repeated misuse of admin tools, dismissive and uncommunicative. Alison, Steel359 Case moved to Arbitration and R.fiend resigned as an admin.
Threeafterthree 15 Dec 2007 Incivility. Toyalla, Binky The WonderSkull Threeafterthree apologized for any offense caused; RFC removed after a month of inactivity.
Gump 13 Dec 2007 Incivility and disruptive editing relating to Rob Bell article. Lyonscc, Virgil Vaduva RfC removed after inactive for over a month with no clear resolution.
COGDEN 12 Dec 2007 COGDEN has been editing policy pages in a disruptive fashion over a period of several months. Dreadstar, Slrubenstein COGDEN is editing in good faith, but perhaps inappropriately, COGDEN reduced contentious editing on policy pages.
Angie Y. 2 11 Dec 2007 "Inserting POV and OR material into articles despite several warnings." Someguy0830, Codelyoko193 Angie to be mentored by Interrobang²
KmWeber 2 11 Dec 2007 User repeatedly using a copy-and-paste unwarranted 'oppose' comment at all self-nominated RfAs. Carl (CBM), Mr.Z-man Consensus appears to favor no action by the community at this time.
Quantumentanglement 16 Dec 2007 Problems with WP:FRINGE issues and wikilawyering. The Evil Spartan, MrWhich Quantumentanglement has been blocked indefinitely.
Bruce1333 8 Dec 2007 POV pushing on articles; disruption Master of Puppets, Kablammo Moot; Bruce1333 indef blocked by Ryulong on 08:30 UTC 2007-12-09
MONGO 3 16 Nov 2007 "a persistent pattern of disruptive editing and personal attacks regarding the "Attack Sites" issue" Alecmconroy, Viridae ArbCom was unwilling to take case, RfC died for lack of interest
EJ220 11 Nov 2007 WP:NPOV, WP:V. Southern Texas, Malik Shabazz EJ220 indefblocked for vandalism.
Billy Hathorn 10 Nov 2007 "Creation of prodigious numbers of non-notable biographies, longest deleted articles log I can recall seeing." JzG, DGG Billy never responded, some discussion at User talk:Billy Hathorn.
Anonimu 27 Oct 2007 POV pushing on articles; disruption; incivility Biruitorul, K. Lastochka Moot; Anonimu indef blocked by Maxim on 02:08 UTC 2007-11-27 and by ArbCom case for a year on 17:20 UTC 2007-12-13
Scipo 19 Oct 2007 Edit-warring, incivility. Wyatt Riot, twsx Scipo indef blocked for sockpuppetry and block evasion (SSP report).
Angel David 19 Oct 2007 POV pushing. First Certifier, Second certifier Delisted due to inactivity with no clear outcome; Walton One and Yamakiri indicated a willingness to mentor Angel David.
Camptown 16 Oct 2007 Adding false information and removing sourced text. Liftarn, panda Delisted due to inactivity.
Geoeg 16 Oct 2007 Disruptive SPA. EdJohnston, Bfigura Geoeg indef blocked by Spartaz (see WP:AN/I discussion).
Sm565 16 Oct 2007 Edit-warring SPA. OrangeMarlin, Skinwalker User indef blocked by Moreschi (log).
Shamir1 16 Oct 2007 Reverting against consensus, disruption. tariqabjotu , okedem Delisted due to inactivity.
Duke53 12 Oct 2007 Incivility, edit warring, POV pushing. alanyst, Masamage Delisted due to inactivity.
Mattisse 2 5 Oct 2007 Edits regarding Drapetomania article. Cyborg Ninja, Malik Shabazz Delisted due to inactivity.
Gavin.collins 4 Oct 2007 Several policy/guideline violations. Turlo_Lomon, SamBC Initially closed due to inactivity. Reopened for admin action, but reclosed due to invalid reasoning, and lack of recent evidence to indicate dispute is still ongoing.
Luisosio 1 Oct 2007 Civility, original research, ownership, POV-pushing. Cleduc, CJLL_Wright Luisosio stopped editing on 9 October 2007.
John Foxe 10 Sep 2007 WP:OWN, WP:NPOV on First Vision article. 74s181 , wrp103 Delisted due to inactivity; discussion continued at Talk:First Vision.
Kmweber 3 Aug 2007 Rude posting in RfAs No outcome, discussion at standstill, opinions are against blocking
NE2 3 21 Oct 2007 Implementing the removal of "decommissioned" without consensus. Rschen7754, Mitchazenia MedCab resolved this issue (mainly content)
Durova 23 Nov 2007 Violation of WP:BLOCK, WP:AGF; request for admin recall. Physchim62, Lsi john Durova has resigned her administrative privileges.
Whig 10 Oct 2007 Repeated violations of WP:GAME, WP:AGF, WP:CIVIL as well as violations of WP:CANVASS and WP:3RR. Adam Cuerden, Wikidudeman Whig has been blocked indefinitely.
Alkivar 27 Jul 2007 Uncivil, misuse of admin position. Videmus Omnia, Rlest Arbitration
Tony Sidaway 4 4 Oct 2007 WP:CIV WP:NPA Viridae, David Levy "Matter was deemed resolved"
Nescio 2 13 Sep 2007 WP:GAME, WP:OWN, WP:OR/WP:SYN, WP:CON Ipankonin, Balloonman Delisted due to inactivity.
Ludovicapipa 6 Sep 2007 WP:OR, WP:NPOV/WP:FRINGE, WP:RS, WP:V Dalillama, KieferSkunk Delisted due to inactivity.
Italiavivi 2 Sep 2007 Disruptive editing Hu12, Zsero Italiavivi stopped editing on 11 September 2007.
Kwork 26 Aug 2007 Disregarding core policies, POV pushing Sethie, Reneeholle Kwork indefinitely blocked for disruption on 27 October 2007.
Commodore Sloat 24 Aug 2007 WP:NPA WP:AGF Bigglove, Isarig Apology offered and accepted; Proposed suggestions if further issues: dual mentorship for CSloat or ArbCom for multiple involved Editors
Chrisjnelson 19 Aug 2007 WP:CIV, WP:NPA, WP:OWN, WP:EDITWAR Jmfangio, Morgan Wick Proceeded to arbitration
DreamGuy 2 7 Aug 2007 WP:CIV, WP:OWN, WP:AGF, WP:NPA Dicklyon, Clpo13 Gone to arbitration
NE2 (Second RFC) 2 Aug 2007 WP:CONS, WP:WL, WP:NOT#BURO, WP:POINT, WP:FUC, WP:CANVASS O, Master son Issues settled.
Artaxerex 31 Jul 2007 WP:NPA, Wikipedia:Civility, Wikipedia:Sock puppetry, WP:NPOV, WP:NOR, WP:EW, WP:BATTLE Shervink, SG Request for arbitration filed here.
Ryulong 30 Jul 2007 WP:BLOCK. The Evil Spartan, Videmus Omnia User cautioned.
Peter morrell 20 Jul 2007 Incivility, personal attacks, NPOV violations Adam Cuerden, Orangemarlin Removed after Cuerden failed to sign in the right place; Morrell apologized
Jeffrey O. Gustafson 10 Jul 2007 WP:CIVIL, WP:CSD, WP:NPA, WP:ADMIN Black Falcon, Drewcifer3000 Proceeded to arbitration
Banno 8 Jul 2007 WP:BLOCK Orangemarlin, Jim62sch Apology issued.
Spartaz 7 Jul 2007 WP:BLOCK Pyrope, Readro Action affirmed.
Angie Y. 5 Jul 2007 WP:CIV, WP:NPA, WP:AGF and WP:CANVASS Seraphim Whipp, Bignole User appears to have changed her behavior.
Alansohn 28 Jun 2007 Wikilawyering, WP:POINT, WP:AGF, WP:NPA Eusebeus, Thewinchester Orginally closed on 14 August 2007, the RfC was re-closed again on 27 May 2008 due to the closure of Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Footnoted quotes which placed Alansohn on a editing restriction for one year.
NE2 22 Jun 2007 Mainly WP:CONS vishwin60, JohnnyAlbert10 Disputes resolved
Assault11 11 Jun 2007 Disruptive editing Cydevil38, Nlu No apparent resolution; stalled with closure of Wikipedia:Requests for mediation/Goguryeo for similar inactivity
Rhode Island Red 9 Jun 2007 WP:NPA, WP:CIV and WP:OWN at Juice Plus Elonka, Matthew User agreed to take a break from editing the article
Mike18xx 6 Jun 2007 WP:MEAT, WP:NPA and other subsequent issues. FayssalF, Proabivouac User agreed to stop recruiting off-wiki meatpuppets
Atabek 7 Jun 2007 Continued false accusations, harassment, and canvassing Hajji Piruz, Tariqabjotu Proceeded to arbitration
Bishonen 2 5 Jun 2007 accused of making false charge of harassment; accused of inappropriate block Ferrylodge, LCP Unanimous rejection of assertions made, with the only exceptions being the persons bringing Rfc.
Martinphi 1 Apr 2007 edit warring, pov-pushing and -forking, spamming, making use of meat puppets, abusing Wikipedia processes to game the system Simoes, Minderbinder No changes; proceeding to arbitration: Paranormal, Martinphi-ScienceApologist.
Tezza1 12 Mar 2007 Disruptive editing, WP:DE, WP:TE, WP:N, WP:POINT, WP:CIVIL, WP:NPOV, WP:COI RPWebslave, The Null Device Proceeded to mediation
KazakhPol 12 Feb 2007 personal attacks, edit warring, calling editors vandals, inserting the word "terrorist" inappropriately into articles about Islamic groups, inappropriate tagging. User:cs, User:Aaliyah Stevens
Logicus 1 February 2007 Repeated disruptive editing involving original research on articles related to the History of Science. SteveMcCluskey, ragesoss Delisted due to inactivity.
Trödel 25 Jan 2007 Abuse of blocking policy. TheGreenFaerae, Viridae Trödel apologized for misuse of blocking and agreed to never block TheGreenFaerae again, though reserves the right to request another administrator to blcok him.
Yamla 30 Jan 2007 Use of blocking to win content disputes. Justen, Mr. Vitale, 71Demon No changes.
Sir Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington 2 18 Feb 2007 Improper closing of AfDs. Balancer, Golden Wattle No conclusion, though noted at time of close that Nick had stopped closing AfDs.
Jimmuldrow 18 Feb 2007 Discussing edits; abiding by consensus; assuming good faith; neutrality; original research. Hydriotaphia, Ferrylodge Although nothing conclusively resolved, all parties seem to be willing to move forward productively; closed per agreement
Essjay 2 Mar 2007 Community Trust issues over fake PHDs, and using them in advantage of content disputes Community certified Closed as Essjay since left the project
Hildanknight 30 Jan 2007 Self-filed RfC over "controversial" edits Hildanknight, no second certifier User opened an ER at Wikipedia:Editor review/Hildanknight as suggested.
StuRat 2 9 Jan 2007 Incivility, use of "deletionist" as pejorative term. TenOfAllTrades, David D. No additional complaints were registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped.
Raspor 3 Jan 2007 "violating WP:NPA, WP:NOT, WP:3RR while dismissing policies governing article content." FeloniousMonk, Ec5618 Account was indefblocked on 18 January 2007 by SlimVirgin and editor was community banned (WP:AN/I discussion).
Suemcp 1 Jan 2007 Edit-warring, incivility, WP:V, WP:RS WP:NPOV and WP:OR violations. Dina, Slp1 Dispute stopped as Suemcp has been inactive since January 9 2007.
Sir Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington 29 Dec 2006 Misuse of admin powers (blocking, deletion), WP:CIVIL Malber, Cindery Nothing resolved, participants tired of arguing.
Tim Smith 29 Dec 2006 "conducting a low-grade edit war and misusing WP processes", ignoring WP:NPOV and giving undue weight to a minority viewpoint. FeloniousMonk, Guettarda No additional complaints were registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped.
BrandonYusufToropov 21 Dec 2006 Personal attacks and incivility. Karl Meier, Coelacan RFC closed by JzG on 16 January 2007: "no further input for 14 days, and no evidence presented of a continuing problem."
Vintila Barbu 17 Dec 2006 Suspicions of plagiarism need discussion. User:Jmabel, User:Dahn Allegation denied, no source identified, paragraph remains in article as unreferenced.
StuRat 13 Dec 2006 Attempting to change customary behavior at Wikipedia:Reference Desk, "a tendency to favor rules-lawyering over discussing the fundamental issue". Hipocrite, Friday RFC did not resolve dispute but "served to clarify somewhat the positions of the disputants" and was superseded by StuRat 2.
Psychohistorian 13 Dec 2006 Abuse and incivility. Fourdee, Thulean Closed after inactive for a month.
BooyakaDell 12 Dec 2006 Edit conflicts, sockpuppet allegations, Notability SirFozzie, Lethaniol User in focus was indefblocked as a Sockpuppet of a banned user via WP:AN
Mitsos 7 Dec 2006 Promoting an admitted political bias, incivility, personal attacks, edit-warring. Spylab, SandyDancer Archived after over a month of inactivity; the RFC "alerted some editors and administrators about the kinds of policy violations Mitsos has committed on Wikipedia ... This page can be used as evidence if other disputes come up regarding the editor" (RFC results discussion).
Kelly Martin 3 6 Dec 2006 RFC filed by Kelly Martin as a forum for editors to air their grievances about her Initial statement of dispute was not certified by other editors due to nonstandard format of RFC. Kelly Martin stopped participating in RFC on 10 December 2006 and RFC was closed after a month of inactivity.
Jance 6 Dec 2006 Violations of WP:CIVIL and WP:AGF. Samir, Sarah Ewart User was indefblocked 21 February 2007 by Cbrown1023 (WP:AN/I discussion).
Piotrus 5 Dec 2006 WP:CIVIL, WP:NPA, WP:AGF, WP:REVERT, WP:WHEEL, WP:NPOV, WP:SPAM, WP:POINT Ghirlandajo, M.K Arbitration
Keltik31 30 Nov 2006 POV-pushing, incivility, personal attacks. Db099221, JoshuaZ User was indefblocked on 10 November 2007 by Addhoc.
Abu badali 29 Nov 2006 Image tagging issues; "concerns about Abu badali's approach to fair-use image challenges" (from subsequent ArbCom case). Irpen, Tvccs Evolved into Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Abu badali.
Seabhcan 18 Nov 2006 Incivility Tom Harrison, Tbeatty Arbitration
RPJ 7 Nov 2006 User:RPJ continues to violate WP:NPOV, WP:NPA, WP:OR, WP:CIVIL and WP:V. Gamaliel, Ramsquire Arbitration
PMA 26 Nov 2006 Misuse of blocking power Thatcher131, Sarah Ewart Resigned sysop position
JR Pietri 13 Aug 2006 WP:CIVIL, WP:SPAM Guinnog, Viridae
Ferick 6 Aug 2006
Snake Liquid 1 Aug 2006
Insert-Belltower 21 Aug 2006
UCRGrad 21 Jul 2006
Francespeabody 20 Jul 2006
Darwinek 18 Jul 2006
Wiarthurhu 16 Jul 2006
Sheynhertz-Unbayg 11 Jul 2006
Telex
(Telex) 		11 Jul 2006
JD UK 2 Jul 2006
Teemu Ruskeepää 29 Jun 2006
Gundagai editor 26 Jul 2006 Gone to arbitration
Irpen 23 Jun 2006
Michaellovesnyc 23 Jun 2006
Brya 22 Jun 2006 Gone to arbitration
Imacomp 22 Jun 2006
Michael D. Wolok 21 Jun 2006
Frater FiatLux 21 Jun 2006
Mines45 21 Jun 2006
Maddyfan 15 Jun 2006
Dr1819 11 Jun 2006
Swainstonation 11 Jun 2006
Rick Norwood 7 Jun 2006
SNIyer12 22 May 2006
Alastor Moody 16 Sep 2006 User has a history of useless and/or irrelevant edits to talk pages (particularly on WikiProject Tropical cyclones), in violation of WP:NOT (a chat room). Coredesat, Hello32020 Withdrawn when the disputed conduct did not recur
CrazyInSane 7 Aug 2006 WP:AGF, WP:CIVIL WP:SOCK, WP:NOR and WP:NPOV issues. JoshuaZ, LtPowers Agreement to close
WikiRoo 10 Jul 2006 POV pushing, personal attacks Garywill, User:AbsolutDan Indef banned by community
Block of Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) 27 Jul 2006 Concerns regarding the block of User:Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ). Note: unlike most RFCs, there is no concern about abuse but rather a concern about broader issues of process drift and precedent. UninvitedCompany Stale
Nescio 14 Jul 2006 Nescio has frequently engaged in violations of WP:POINT to the detrement of the articles he edits. Zer0faults, Rangeley Stale; Nescio has left Wikipedia
Kelly Martin2 8 Aug 2006 Forming a new policy in order to close off ongoing discussion pertaining to an issue Johntex, Mecu Kelly Martin has left Wikipedia, also similar issues were raised in an unrelated arbitration case.
Vivaldi 20 May 2006 POV editing, ignoring consensus Arbustoo, FeloniousMonk Arbitration
Sceptre 2 Aug 2006 Blocking of ed g2s Sceptre, Johntex Sceptre is no longer an admin
MONGO 24 Jun 2006 Misuse of blocking power Pokipsy76, CBD Arbitration for similar issues
BenH 26 Jun 2006 Poor or unverifiable contributions, does not respond on talk pages CFIF, CoolKatt number 99999 Indef banned by community
Der alte Hexenmeister 19 Jun 2006 POV pushing, uncivil behavior, vandalism ems57fcva,Chris Hillman User is no longer active in Wikipedia
Hatto 9 Jun 2006 Extremely uncooperative user; vandalism, reverts, copywrite problems, non-communication, disruption, edit warring, NPOV, disregard for policy, more. freshgavin, Geo.plrd, "Numorous sic other users listing complains sic on Hatto's talk pages", Mackan Stale
Lupo 13 May 2006 Abuse of admin rules in ruling and POV of Soviet pre-1973 images Kuban kazak, Grafikm fr Stale
Ed Poor (2) 31 May 2006 Imposing his own POV FeloniousMonk, Ladlergo Arbitration
Ericsaindon2 5 Jun 2006 POV pushing and original research Will Beback, Adambiswanger1 Sent to arbitration
Brian G. Crawford 18 May 2006 Bad faith nomintions at AfD, personal attacks, template misuse, assuming bad faith, and incivility Backburner001, Apyule Community ban
CoolKatt number 99999 17 May 2006 Incivility Kafziel,CFIF Sent to arbitration
Gene Nygaard 10 May 2006 Persistently imposes his own style preferences on scientific articles Worldtraveller, Sadi Carnot Stale
Xino 5 May 2006 Abrasiveness Golbez, Waka
Hamsacharya dan 30 Apr 2006 POV pushing Hanuman Das, Computerjoe
TheKingOfDixie 29 Apr 2006 Refusing to accept consensus Threeafterthree, Shenme
Pat8722 27 Apr 2006 Revert war at Libertarianism Rhobite, Cadr Arbitration
Kurt Leyman 26 Apr 2006 Adding unverifiable information SuperDeng, Grafikm fr
Adam Carr 23 Apr 2006 Personal attacks Zleitzen, BruceHallman
Israelbeach 23 Apr 2006 Using Wikipedia to promote his own interests. Woggly, Jpgordon Banned for posting personal information [2]
Fadix 22 Apr 2006 Lack of civility Cool Cat, Grandmaster
86.10.231.219 22 Apr 2006 Trolling Midgley, Jfdwolff
Whaleto 13 Apr 2006 Adding links to his own alternative medicine web site to medical topics in violation of WP:V and WP:RS Midgley, Tearlach
Merecat 13 Apr 2006 POV pushing Nescio, Kevin Baas Banned as a reincarnation of Rex071404
Mccready 4 Apr 2006 POV pushing on chiropractic articles Ombudsman, R. Koot
Ombudsman 2 Nov 2005 POV pushing on vaccine topics Jfdwolff, Geni

But he persists with the attacks in the talk pages (most of this has been archived) and in his edit summaries. Please help. Nrets 04:33, 29 January 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Earlier conflicts

See Wikipedia:Conflicts between users/archive1.

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Requests_for_comment/User_conduct/Archive&oldid=537462453"