Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Morgan: Difference between revisions
del |
|||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
*The above vote is by yet another user whose only edit is that vote. '''Delete'''. --[[User:fvw|fvw]][[User talk:Fvw|<SMALL><FONT COLOR="green">*</FONT></SMALL>]] 20:47, 2005 Jan 20 (UTC) |
*The above vote is by yet another user whose only edit is that vote. '''Delete'''. --[[User:fvw|fvw]][[User talk:Fvw|<SMALL><FONT COLOR="green">*</FONT></SMALL>]] 20:47, 2005 Jan 20 (UTC) |
||
'''Do Not Delete.''' Just as Cruachan153 was weeping about, you can't just delete a page because your sources don't show it. There is plenty of information about this author, he is my favorite. I plan to father his children. |
|||
Revision as of 20:56, 20 January 2005
Either vanity or non-notable, take your pick. RickK 09:30, Jan 20, 2005 (UTC)
- Both? Delete Lectonar 11:48, 20 Jan 2005 (UTC)
- Delete. "An obscure fiction author". Indeed. - Jpo 12:42, Jan 20, 2005 (UTC)
- That could be either an author of fiction that is obscure, or a fiction author that is obscure. It seems to be both. The book mentioned is real (ISBN 1411606868). Delete. Uncle G 14:38, 2005 Jan 20 (UTC)
- Do Not Delete - Information on all writers and books is useful. Just below in the VfD section a user mentioned that they study writers and all information, no matter how "non-notable" it may seem to you, is useful. The book is indeed real, and was easily found on amazon and barnes and noble. Non-notable? (CaptainAggro according to history Uncle G 20:11, 2005 Jan 20 (UTC))
- You are referring to Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Claudia Keenan where Cruachan153, the original author of the article, cast a vote in favour of its retention on the grounds that xe found the news in xyr own article helpful for xyr study. I'd be wary of using that as a basis for argument. Uncle G 20:11, 2005 Jan 20 (UTC)
Do not delete - Have done extensive research on this author and he is a brilliant up and coming writer. First hand research has shown that the man is indeed a popular sex symbol in the northwest US. Sean Morgan is now thought to have sired at least 50 children in 20 states. Furthermore, he has written under pen names many erotic short stories and occassional informational pamplets an the stimulation of a woman's g-spot. We would be doing the world a disservice by deleting this entry.
- The above vote is by yet another user whose only edit is that vote. Delete. --fvw* 20:47, 2005 Jan 20 (UTC)
Do Not Delete. Just as Cruachan153 was weeping about, you can't just delete a page because your sources don't show it. There is plenty of information about this author, he is my favorite. I plan to father his children.