Jump to content

User contributions for 76.141.98.189

Results for 76.141.98.189 talk block log logs global block log filter log
Search for contributionsshowhide
⧼contribs-top⧽
⧼contribs-date⧽

10 January 2024

  • 04:3204:32, 10 January 2024 diff hist +404 Eruption of Mount Vesuvius in 79 AD Nature of the eruption: This, like other appearances of material on Pliny and the eruption, is very poorly sourced, given the available scholarly work on this subject. This, like the shorter descriptions that link to it, violates WP:VERIFY and likely WP:OR. This is all material thrust on readers with a demand for trust, in defiance of Wikipedia's disclaimer, policies, which state its veracity comes from its sources. Worse, this appears to have been going on for years, without resolution.
  • 04:1804:18, 10 January 2024 diff hist +263 Stabiae The Eruption of 79 AD: Noting fact that material in this section is essentially unverifiable, apart from account of Pliny's death given in primary source—and there we have no modern scholarly, secondary source indicating that account should be believed. Closing volcanology material is also unverifiable; source of last sentence is unclear (drawn from Francis & Oppenheimer or other), and fact that no pg no. in that long book is given also violates WP:VERIFY.

8 January 2024

29 December 2023

26 December 2023